The Paper Trail
The Paper TrailFind a Firm

How to check a broker-dealer: BrokerCheck, EDGAR reports, Form CRS and SIPC

A broker-dealer can be checked by searching FINRA BrokerCheck for its registration and reported disclosures, looking up its annual audited report, Form X-17A-5, on the SEC's EDGAR system, reading its Form CRS if it serves retail customers, and confirming SIPC membership. These are the public records available as of Nov. 10, 2026, and The Paper Trail combines them into five factors.

Is FINRA BrokerCheck legit?

FINRA BrokerCheck is the free service of FINRA, the self-regulatory organization for broker-dealers, and it draws its information from the Central Registration Depository (CRD), according to the BrokerCheck FAQ. The FAQ says the information is reported by firms, investment professionals and regulators on registration forms, that reports are free, and that neither firms nor individuals are told about a search.

Registered firms and professionals are generally required to update their CRD information within 30 days. To verify that a firm is registered with FINRA, the FAQ says to check the Registrations section of its BrokerCheck report; every firm on BrokerCheck is currently or was previously registered, but there is no current information for firms not presently registered.

How do you check a broker-dealer?

A reader checks a broker-dealer by combining records from FINRA, the SEC, SIPC and state regulators, because each holds a different part of the record. The table lists each record, where to find it and what it shows. No single record covers everything: BrokerCheck omits some kinds of complaints, and the SEC's action lookup covers individuals only.

Eight records for checking a broker-dealer, where to find each and what it shows (sources read Nov. 10, 2026)
RecordWhereWhat it shows
BrokerCheck firm reportBrokerCheck; rule: FINRA Rule 8312Information on the most recently filed Form BD, currently approved registrations, summary information about certain arbitration awards against the firm involving a public customer, and the firm's succession history
FINRA disciplinary actionsLinked from BrokerCheck (FAQ)FINRA disciplinary actions issued in 2005 or later that are eligible for publication
FINRA arbitration awardsArbitration Awards OnlineAwards searchable free of charge; the database may not show whether a court confirmed, modified or vacated an award
SEC action lookupSEC Action Look-Up, IndividualsIndividuals, not firms, named as defendants or respondents in SEC actions filed Oct. 1, 1995 to Sept. 24, 2025, with a judgment or order entered; pending cases are not included
Annual audited report, Form X-17A-5 Part IIISEC EDGARThe firm's annual financial report and its compliance or exemption report, filed electronically for audits filed on or after June 30, 2025
Form CRSThe firm; BrokerCheck lists a Form CRS on file for retail-facing firmsA relationship summary for retail investors; a firm with no retail investors to deliver one to is not required to prepare or file one
SIPC membershipSIPCWhether the firm is a SIPC member; SIPC says to check its list or contact it
State securities regulatorNASAA, Contact Your RegulatorContact information and resources for state and provincial securities regulators

What does BrokerCheck leave out?

BrokerCheck leaves out information that firms and professionals have not reported or are not required to report. Per the FAQ, examples include non-investment-related civil litigation, complaints from customers that make no allegation of sales practice violations, fraud or theft, and previously reported judgments or liens that have been satisfied.

Under FINRA Rule 8312(e), eligible firms may dispute the accuracy of certain information, and FINRA adds a notation to the report while it investigates. The FAQ also says information may be expunged from the CRD system in certain limited circumstances, most often under a court order.

What are common broker red flags?

FINRA's investor page on red flags lists ten warning signs of investment fraud: guarantees, unsolicited offers, requests for secrecy, unregistered products, unlicensed or unregistered sellers, overly consistent returns, complex strategies, account discrepancies, unusual asset-holding arrangements and pushy salespeople. The FINRA page frames the signs around investment sellers and professionals, and says other red flags can be harder to spot than the ones it lists.

  • Guarantees: a promise that an investment will perform a certain way or earn a lofty return, though FINRA says all investments carry some risk.
  • Unsolicited offers: cold calls, texts, emails, mailers, commercials or social media posts that are overly attractive or fear-inducing.
  • Requests for secrecy: a seller who says not to tell anyone about the investment, or who asks the buyer to bring in people they know.
  • Unregistered products: securities sold with no documentation, such as no prospectus for a stock or mutual fund or no offering documents for a bond or private placement, or stocks without symbols.
  • Unlicensed or unregistered sellers, including imposters that misuse the name of a real registered professional or firm.
  • Overly consistent returns: an investment that rises month after month or pays remarkably steady returns whatever the market does.
  • Complex strategies: someone who credits a highly complex technique for unusual success instead of explaining clearly what they do.
  • Account discrepancies: unauthorized trades, missing funds or other statement problems, which FINRA says could be an error or could indicate churning or fraud.
  • Unusual asset-holding arrangements: the investment professional also acting as custodian, a request to send money to the person instead of the registered firm, or a request to use a specific trading platform.
  • Pushy salespeople: pressure to decide right away.

FINRA's list is of fraud warning signs, not a count of how often each appears. A seller's registration can be looked up on BrokerCheck, whose limits the previous section describes.

How do the site's five factors map to those records?

The Paper Trail scores five factors for a broker-dealer under its broker-dealer rubric, whose current version is on the methodology page: regulatory record (35%), legal record (10%), customer dispute record (15%), financial condition (30%) and operating history (10%). The score describes the firm's public regulatory and financial record; it is not advice and never rates individuals.

The five factors and weights in The Paper Trail's broker-dealer rubric, which covers the 484 West broker-dealers in the index (rubric read Nov. 10, 2026; firm count as of Nov. 9, 2026)
FactorWeightInput
Regulatory record35%Final regulatory matters against the firm on its BrokerCheck (CRD) record
Legal record10%Final civil judicial, criminal, financial and judgment or lien matters on the firm's CRD record
Customer dispute record15%FINRA arbitration awards with the firm as respondent
Financial condition30%Net capital against the required minimum, a material-weakness flag and going-concern language in the latest electronic Form X-17A-5 annual report
Operating history10%Years registered with FINRA

When does a factor show as not scored, and what about pending matters?

A broker-dealer score factor shows as N/A, meaning not scored, when its input is missing, and the remaining weights are renormalized over the factors that are scored. Missing data is never scored as good or bad. Pending matters and allegations are shown on profiles and never scored; only final matters score.

  • No BrokerCheck report, or counts that do not reconcile: regulatory, legal and customer dispute factors are N/A.
  • A non-retail firm with no arbitration awards: the customer dispute factor is N/A. A retail firm, one with a Form CRS on file in BrokerCheck, is always scored.
  • No electronic Form X-17A-5, an unreadable net capital figure or a stale report: financial condition is N/A.
  • No registration date: operating history is N/A.

Settled arbitration cases are not public, so a clean record on the page does not mean no complaints, and the page says so.

What do The Paper Trail's West broker-dealer figures show?

Among the 484 West broker-dealers in the index, 156 (32.2%) have any final regulatory event on their BrokerCheck record and 68 (14.0%) have one resolved in the last five years, as of Nov. 9, 2026. And 35 (7.2%) have a customer arbitration award to a claimant. These are shares of the firms in the index, not ratings of any firm.

Record measures for the 484 West broker-dealers in the index (n = 484; BrokerCheck and X-17A-5 captures dated Nov. 9, 2026)
MeasureFigureBase
Any final regulatory event, any date32.2% (156 firms)484 firms
Final regulatory event resolved on or after Nov. 9, 202114.0% (68 firms)484 firms
Customer arbitration award to a claimant7.2% (35 firms)484 firms; settled cases are not public
Median final regulatory fine$15,000798 final firm-scope matters with a fine
Median net capital multiple17.06263 firms (net capital divided by the required minimum)

A broker-dealer's net capital multiple is read from the firm's latest electronic Form X-17A-5 annual report, and only for firms where the report text states both figures and the extractor read them, so it covers 263 of the 484 firms. For three West examples by net capital, see Osaic Wealth, Inc., D.A. Davidson & Co. and Wealthfront Brokerage LLC.

The Paper Trail's broker-dealer hub, its broker-dealer methodology and all 13 West states cover the firms in this guide. Related guides: what is a broker-dealer and disclosures, regulatory actions, arbitration and pending matters.

Sources