A fiduciary must put the client's interest first, and registered investment advisers owe that duty to their advisory clients under federal law. When the same person sells a security as a broker or a policy as an insurance agent, that sale is made in a different role, under different rules, and it can pay a commission that an advisory fee does not.
In practice, a client of one of the 77 Northwest firms may deal with someone who acts as an adviser on one account and as a salesperson on another.
What the filings show
| Fiduciary only when advising | Fiduciary at all times | |
|---|---|---|
| Firms | 77 | 25 |
| Share of the 102 firms | 75% | 25% |
| Disclose insurance sales | 74 | 0 |
| Disclose commissions | 67 | 0 |
| List licensed insurance agents on staff | 72 | 2 |
| Report staff who are broker-dealer representatives | 34 | 0 |
| Individual clients | 112,607 | 26,818 |
| Regulatory assets under management | $126.7 billion | $87.2 billion |
Seventy-two list licensed insurance agents among their employees on Form ADV, and 34 report employees who are also registered representatives of a broker-dealer.
Together the 77 Northwest advisers report 112,607 individual clients, including high-net-worth individuals, and $126.7 billion in regulatory assets under management. The 25 firms that are fiduciaries at all times report 26,818 individual clients and $87.2 billion.
How the line is drawn
The Paper Trail applies one rule to every firm. A firm is classified as a fiduciary only when advising if the firm or its people sell commissioned securities or insurance, as shown in its Form ADV answers on compensation, other business activities and affiliates, or as stated in its brochure or relationship summary. A firm is a fiduciary at all times when it reports no commission or insurance business anywhere and states that it acts as a fiduciary to its advisory clients.
For fiduciary classification, holding an insurance license is not enough by itself. Two of the 25 firms list licensed insurance agents on staff, but their filings don't say anyone earns commissions, so they remain in the at-all-times group. No firm's filings were too unclear to classify.
Being a fiduciary at all times doesn't mean a firm has no conflicts of interest. All 25 disclose at least one, and all 25 disclose benefits from the custodians that hold their clients' accounts.
The 25 firms that are fiduciaries at all times
- Avier Wealth Advisors
- Becker Capital Management
- Brighton Jones
- Cutler Investment Group
- Evergreen Capital Management
- Ferguson Wellman Capital Management
- Financial Insights Wealth Management
- Financial Plan
- First Pacific Financial
- JGP Wealth Management
- Leonard Rickey Investment Advisors, P.L.L.C.
- LNW
- Marsjewett Financial Group
- Next Level Wealth Planning
- Northern Capital Management
- Pacific Sage Partners
- Petersen Hastings Wealth Advisors
- Phillips and Company Advisors
- Quantum Financial Planning Services
- Threadline Wealth
- Tradewinds Capital Management
- Venturi Private Wealth
- Vision Capital Management
- Vista Capital Partners
- Wood Tarver Financial
How we did this: The Paper Trail read the Form ADV Part 2A brochures, Form CRS and Form ADV Part 1 of the 102 SEC-registered advisers headquartered in Washington, Oregon or Idaho that serve at least 500 individual clients and get at least half of their managed assets from individuals. Fiduciary status follows the rule described above, using Form ADV Items 5E, 6A and 7A and the firms' own statements, each recorded with its supporting quote. Client counts are Form ADV Items 5D(a)(1) and 5D(b)(1); assets are Item 5F(2)(c). Details are in our methodology.
Sources
- The Paper Trail datasets behind this report: Hand-decoded SEC-registered investment advisers (CSV); Northwest adviser fees and conflicts (CSV); The tables in this report, one row per cell (CSV).