What is the difference between a fiduciary and a broker?
An investment adviser is a fiduciary under federal law, while a broker-dealer must act in a retail customer's best interest when it makes a recommendation. The SEC's 2019 interpretation says an adviser's fiduciary duty applies to the entire adviser-client relationship. The SEC's Reg BI guide says a broker-dealer must act in the retail customer's best interest at the time a recommendation is made.
| Standard | Applies to | When it applies | Key obligations | Source rule |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advisers Act fiduciary duty | Investment advisers, including state-registered and exempt advisers | The entire adviser-client relationship | Duty of care (best-interest advice, best execution, advice and monitoring at a frequency in the client's best interest) and duty of loyalty (eliminate or fully disclose conflicts); cannot be waived | SEC Release IA-5248 (2019), interpreting section 206 of the Advisers Act |
| Regulation Best Interest | Broker-dealers and their associated persons | When recommending a securities transaction or an investment strategy involving securities, including account types, to a retail customer | Disclosure, Care, Conflict of Interest and Compliance obligations | Exchange Act Rule 15l-1 (Regulation Best Interest) |
| FINRA suitability | FINRA member firms and associated persons | When recommending a transaction or investment strategy involving securities, except recommendations subject to Reg BI | Reasonable-basis, customer-specific and quantitative suitability | FINRA Rule 2111 |
Does a financial advisor have a fiduciary duty?
Whether a financial advisor has a fiduciary duty depends on the registration behind the title, because the SEC and NASAA note that titles and licenses are not the same. An investment adviser is a fiduciary under federal law; a broker-dealer representative recommending to a retail customer follows Regulation Best Interest instead. For a dually registered professional, the SEC says the standard depends on the capacity in which the person is acting.
The SEC adds that Reg BI does not apply to investment advice a dual registrant gives as an investment adviser, even when the customer also has a brokerage relationship with it. The titles vs. registrations guide and the registration-check guide show how to find which registration applies. For advisers, the SEC notes that case law, other statutes and state law can add obligations, and that those standards may differ.
What are the four obligations of Regulation Best Interest?
Regulation Best Interest requires a broker-dealer to act in the best interest of a retail customer when recommending a securities transaction or investment strategy, without putting its own financial or other interest ahead. The SEC's compliance guide says this general obligation is met only by complying with four component obligations: Disclosure, Care, Conflict of Interest and Compliance.
- Disclosure: provide required disclosure, in writing, before or at the time of the recommendation, about the recommendation and the relationship, including material fees and conflicts of interest.
- Care: use reasonable diligence, care and skill, including a reasonable basis to believe the recommendation is in the particular customer's best interest and that a series of transactions is not excessive.
- Conflict of interest: establish, maintain and enforce written policies and procedures reasonably designed to address conflicts of interest.
- Compliance: establish, maintain and enforce written policies and procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the rule.
A "retail customer" is a natural person, or that person's legal representative, who receives a recommendation and uses it primarily for personal, family or household purposes. Reg BI's effective date was Sept. 10, 2019 and its compliance date was June 30, 2020. The existing guide on fiduciary duty and Regulation Best Interest covers the rule's details, and the Form CRS guide covers the relationship summary.
What is the FINRA suitability rule, and where does it still apply?
FINRA Rule 2111, the suitability rule, requires a member or associated person to have a reasonable basis to believe a recommended transaction or investment strategy involving securities is suitable for the customer, based on the customer's investment profile. FINRA's rule text says it is made up of three obligations: reasonable-basis, customer-specific and quantitative suitability.
- Reasonable-basis: a reasonable basis, from reasonable diligence, to believe the recommendation is suitable for at least some investors.
- Customer-specific: a reasonable basis to believe it is suitable for a particular customer, based on that customer's investment profile (age, other investments, financial situation and needs, tax status, objectives, experience, time horizon, liquidity needs and risk tolerance).
- Quantitative: a reasonable basis to believe a series of recommended transactions is not excessive when taken together; turnover rate, cost-equity ratio and in-and-out trading may bear on it.
Rule 2111 itself says in Supplementary Material .08 that it does not apply to recommendations subject to Reg BI, and it shows an amendment effective June 30, 2020. The rule's text also covers institutional accounts in paragraph (b). FINRA's suitability FAQ describes an institutional account as one held by a bank, savings and loan association, insurance company, registered investment company, registered investment adviser or any other person with total assets of at least $50 million.
Reg BI's definition of retail customer excludes recommendations to natural persons seeking services for commercial or business purposes, per the SEC's compliance guide. Suitability also appears inside the adviser standard: the SEC says an adviser's duty of care includes providing advice that is suitable for the client.
How can a reader tell which standard applies to a firm?
A reader can tell which standard applies by checking whether the firm is registered as an investment adviser, a broker-dealer or both, using the SEC's IAPD and FINRA's BrokerCheck. FINRA says both SEC-registered RIAs and broker-dealers must furnish Form CRS, which helps compare the services and costs of the two kinds of firm.
When working with a dually registered professional, FINRA says it is important to find out which hat the person is wearing, as investment adviser representative or registered representative. The adviser directory and the broker-dealer hub on The Paper Trail list firms in each category, and the methodology page has the rules; the site's adviser scoring method gives fiduciary standing 5% of an adviser's rating, a weight in effect as of the Oct. 14, 2026 scoring run.
Is there a certificate or license that shows an adviser is a fiduciary?
No certificate or license is named in the pages read as proof that an adviser is a fiduciary: the SEC and NASAA say titles and licenses are not the same, and an investment adviser registered under the Advisers Act is a fiduciary under federal law, per the SEC's 2019 interpretation. The independent check is the adviser's registration on IAPD, where the Form ADV and Form CRS state the standard the firm follows, as of Nov. 10, 2026.
A professional designation can carry its own standard: the CFP Board says a CFP professional must act as a fiduciary when providing financial advice. That is a private organization's rule, not a government registration, and the CFP Board's website lets a reader verify a CFP certification.
Sources
- Focus on Ethics: CFP Professionals' Fiduciary Duty When Providing Financial Advice (CFP Board)
- Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (SEC)
- Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, Release IA-5248 (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest: A Small Entity Compliance Guide (SEC)
- Making Sense of Financial Professional Titles (SEC and NASAA investor bulletin)
- FINRA Rule 2111, Suitability (FINRA)
- Suitability FAQ (FINRA)
- Investment Advisers (FINRA)