What does a fiduciary do?
A fiduciary must act for another party's benefit rather than its own, and what that requires depends on the role, as of Nov. 11, 2026. An investment adviser's duty of care includes best-interest advice, best execution and monitoring, and its duty of loyalty bars putting its own interest first, per the SEC's 2019 interpretation. A trustee holds legal title to trust property for the beneficiaries and owes duties such as loyalty, prudent administration, keeping trust property separate and reporting to beneficiaries, per the OCC's Comptroller's Handbook.
What is an investment adviser's fiduciary duty?
In a 2019 interpretation, the SEC said an investment adviser's fiduciary duty under the Investment Advisers Act comprises a duty of care and a duty of loyalty, and applies to the entire relationship between adviser and client. The duty cannot be waived. Its scope can be shaped by agreement, but a contract saying the adviser will not act as a fiduciary, or a blanket waiver of all conflicts, would be inconsistent with the law, the SEC said.
An adviser's duty of care includes giving advice in the client's best interest, seeking the best execution of trades when the adviser chooses the broker, and providing advice and monitoring over the course of the relationship. How much monitoring depends on the arrangement: an adviser paid an ongoing asset-based fee has a relatively extensive duty, the SEC said, while, absent an agreement otherwise, one hired for a one-time financial plan is unlikely to have a duty to monitor.
An adviser's duty of loyalty means the adviser may not put its own interests ahead of the client's. It must eliminate conflicts of interest or disclose them fully and fairly so the client can give informed consent. The SEC added that disclosure and consent do not, by themselves, satisfy the duty to act in the client's best interest.
What is the broker's best-interest standard under Regulation Best Interest?
Regulation Best Interest was adopted under the Securities Exchange Act, FINRA notes, and firms had to comply starting June 30, 2020, according to the SEC's compliance guide. It requires a broker-dealer recommending a securities transaction or investment strategy to a retail customer to act in the customer's best interest at the time the recommendation is made, without placing its own financial or other interest ahead of the customer's.
A retail customer is a person, or a person's legal representative, who uses the recommendation primarily for personal, family or household purposes. The standard also covers recommendations of account types, such as IRA rollovers or opening a brokerage or advisory account, according to FINRA's investor guide.
Regulation Best Interest's general obligation is satisfied only if the broker complies with four component obligations:
- Disclosure: written disclosure of material facts about the relationship and conflicts, before or at the time of the recommendation.
- Care: reasonable diligence, care and skill to understand the risks, rewards and costs of a recommendation and to have a reasonable basis to believe it is in the customer's best interest; a series of transactions must not be excessive.
- Conflict of interest: written policies to identify and disclose or eliminate conflicts, to mitigate incentives for individual brokers, and to eliminate sales contests, quotas, bonuses and non-cash compensation tied to selling specific securities within a limited period.
- Compliance: written policies and procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with the rule.
Where do fiduciary duty and Regulation Best Interest differ?
One practical difference between the adviser and broker standards is monitoring. Regulation Best Interest does not impose a duty to monitor a customer's account, the SEC's guide says. If a broker agrees to monitor an account, the recommendations that come out of those reviews are covered, including an implicit recommendation to hold when the broker stays silent, the same guide says.
An SEC staff bulletin on care obligations says the standards may differ in some respects and be triggered at different times, but in the staff's view generally yield substantially similar results for retail investors. The staff says both require understanding the investment and the investor, and considering reasonably available alternatives.
What does "when acting as your adviser" mean for a dual registrant?
Dual registration is common: many firms, and many individual professionals, are registered as both brokers and advisers. The SEC tells investors working with such a professional to make sure they understand when the professional is acting as a broker and when as an adviser.
The required wording in a firm's Form CRS is conditional. An adviser's summary says the firm has to act in the client's best interest and not put its own interest ahead of the client's. A broker's says the same applies "when we provide you with a recommendation."
Which capacity a dual registrant is acting in when it makes a recommendation is a facts-and-circumstances test with no one factor determinative, according to SEC staff FAQs. Factors include the type of account, how it is described, the type of compensation and how clearly the capacity was disclosed. When a dually registered professional evaluating which account to recommend to a potential customer has not yet clearly disclosed the capacity in which he or she is acting, the staff's view is that the professional should assume both Regulation Best Interest and the Advisers Act apply.
What does the word "adviser" in a title tell you?
Under Regulation Best Interest, the SEC presumes that a broker-dealer not also registered as an investment adviser, or a broker's representative who is not also a supervised person of an adviser, violates the rule's capacity disclosure requirement by using "adviser" or "advisor" in a name or title, according to the compliance guide. A title alone, however, does not show which hat a dual-registered professional is wearing for a given recommendation.
Where can you check whether a firm acts as an adviser or a broker?
An adviser's Form ADV brochure must disclose, under Item 10, whether the firm or its managers are registered as a broker-dealer or a broker's representative. The brochure supplement for an individual discloses other investment-related business and any sales-based pay. Both are available through the SEC's adviser database.
Sources
- Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, Release IA-5248 (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest: A Small Entity Compliance Guide (SEC)
- Frequently Asked Questions on Regulation Best Interest (SEC)
- Staff Bulletin: Standards of Conduct for Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers, Care Obligations (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest, Form CRS and related interpretations (SEC)
- Form CRS instructions (SEC)
- SEC Regulation Best Interest and Form CRS: What You Need to Know (FINRA)
- Form ADV Part 2 instructions (SEC)