The Paper Trail
The Paper TrailFind a Firm

Disclosures explained: regulatory actions, complaints, arbitration and pending matters

A disclosure is an event a broker, adviser or firm reports in its public record, such as a regulatory action, customer complaint, arbitration claim or award, or court matter. A regulatory action is brought by an agency, an arbitration is a binding dispute process, and pending means no final outcome yet, as of Nov. 10, 2026. FINRA arbitration claims over $100,000 go to a panel of three arbitrators.

The Paper Trail shows pending matters on profiles and never scores them.

What is a disclosure on BrokerCheck or IAPD?

A disclosure is a reported event in an investment professional's or firm's record. On BrokerCheck, FINRA Rule 8312 says FINRA releases any information reported on the most recently filed registration forms. For advisers, Form ADV Part 1A, Item 11, "Disclosure Information," asks about the firm's and its advisory affiliates' disciplinary history, and a "yes" answer requires a Disclosure Reporting Page (DRP).

Form ADV Part 1A Item 11 has criminal, regulatory action and civil judicial action sections. An SEC-registered adviser may limit its disclosure of Item 11 events to ten years after the event. The brochure adds its own item: Form ADV Part 2, Item 9, requires disclosure of legal or disciplinary events material to a client's evaluation of the advisory business or the integrity of its management.

What is a regulatory action?

A regulatory action is an action by a government regulator or self-regulatory organization against a firm or person. FINRA Rule 8312(c) says a final regulatory action, as Form U4 defines it, can cover a final action, even one on appeal, by the SEC, the CFTC, a federal banking agency, the NCUA or another federal agency, a state or foreign regulator, or a self-regulatory organization.

Form ADV Item 11.C asks, for example, whether the SEC or CFTC has ever found the adviser or an affiliate to have made a false statement or omission. BrokerCheck does not release information about regulatory investigations or proceedings that the instituting authority vacated or withdrew. FINRA disciplinary actions issued in 2005 or later that are eligible for publication are available on FINRA Disciplinary Actions Online.

What are some common FINRA violations?

FINRA's own list of findings is its 2026 Annual Regulatory Oversight Report, dated December 2025, which gives select findings from recent reviews, examinations, market surveillance, investigations and enforcement activities, topic by topic; it is not a count or ranking of violations. Findings it lists include written procedures not reasonably designed for Regulation Best Interest account recommendations, and Form CRS filings that depart from the instructions or are not delivered, posted or amended as required.

  • Manipulative trading: surveillance deficiencies, such as not performing timely reviews of surveillance alerts or exception reports (FINRA report).
  • Outside business activities and private securities transactions: interpreting "selling compensation" too narrowly and not documenting supervision of a person's participation (FINRA report).
  • Form CRS: inaccurately describing a firm's or its associated persons' disciplinary history, and failing to post the current Form CRS where retail investors can easily find it (FINRA report).

FINRA says the report does not represent a complete inventory of regulatory obligations, findings or topics. Actions against individual firms are listed month by month on FINRA's disciplinary actions page.

What is a customer complaint?

A customer complaint is a customer's allegation of misconduct against an investment professional or firm. FINRA says professionals must notify it of customer complaints that allege misconduct tied to selling financial products, whether or not the allegations have merit, and a BrokerCheck report contains most of them.

FINRA adds that a complaint, by itself, does not show that the investment professional did anything wrong. A complaint can be denied, after which the customer may file a claim in arbitration, or it can be settled. The BrokerCheck FAQ says complaints that do not allege sales practice violations, fraud or theft are not disclosed.

What are an arbitration claim and an arbitration award?

An arbitration claim is a request to a neutral arbitrator to resolve a dispute, and an arbitration award is the arbitrator's decision. FINRA says arbitration is a formal process in which parties select a neutral third party, the arbitrator, to resolve a dispute, and the arbitrator or panel renders a final and binding decision.

The amount of a FINRA arbitration claim sets how it is heard: claims over $100,000 require a hearing by a panel of three arbitrators, smaller claims go to one arbitrator, and claims up to $50,000 may be decided on the written materials under the Simplified Arbitration Process. FINRA says the arbitration case is confidential but awards are publicly available, and its Arbitration Awards Online database is searchable free of charge. Under SRO rules, broker-dealers must arbitrate disputes with customers if the customer chooses to, the SEC's guide says.

BrokerCheck shows summary information about certain arbitration awards against a firm involving a public customer. On The Paper Trail, only an award of money to the claimant counts toward a broker-dealer's customer dispute record; denied claims do not. By the site's method, settled cases are not public.

What does pending mean, compared with final?

A pending matter is one with no final outcome yet, while a final matter has a resolution. In The Paper Trail's broker-dealer scoring, only final matters with an outcome against the firm count; pending and on-appeal matters are shown but not scored. The SEC's action lookup page shows the same line: its results leave out individuals whose cases are still pending in the trial court and individuals against whom no judgment or order has been issued.

Regulators' treatment of appeals is not uniform. FINRA Rule 8312(c) treats a final regulatory action that is on appeal as a final action, while The Paper Trail lists "On Appeal" matters separately and does not score them. Form ADV Item 11 lets an SEC-registered adviser limit its answer about felony charges to charges that are currently pending.

Why does The Paper Trail show pending matters but never score them?

The Paper Trail shows pending matters and allegations on profiles and never scores them, as a matter of site policy stated in its broker-dealer scoring notes. Its adviser scoring notes say the same: pending matters and allegations are shown but never scored. The hedge fund scoring notes say pending or on-appeal matters are shown and never scored.

Missing data is likewise never scored as good or bad, and settled arbitration cases are not public, so a clean record on a profile does not mean no complaints. See the broker-dealer methodology and the adviser methodology.

How do the four terms compare?

The table of the four disclosure terms sets them side by side: what each means, where it appears in public records, and how The Paper Trail treats it for broker-dealers. The first three rows describe record types, and the fourth describes a status that any of them can have.

Four record terms compared by meaning, where each appears and how The Paper Trail treats it (definitions table; sources read Nov. 10, 2026)
TermWhat it meansWhere it appearsHow The Paper Trail treats it
Regulatory actionAn action by an agency or self-regulatory organization against a firm or personBrokerCheck, IAPD (Form ADV Item 11), FINRA Disciplinary Actions OnlineFinal firm-level matters with an outcome against the firm are scored; pending matters are shown, not scored
Customer complaintA customer's allegation of misconduct, which can be denied or settledBrokerCheck reports for professionalsThe broker-dealer customer dispute factor uses arbitration awards, not complaints
Arbitration claim or awardA claim filed with a neutral arbitrator, and the final and binding decision on itArbitration Awards Online; BrokerCheck arbitration sectionOnly awards of money to the claimant are scored; settled cases are not public
Pending matterA matter with no final outcome yetAny of the records aboveShown on profiles, never scored

For how to look these records up, see how to check a broker-dealer and how to check an adviser's registration. The broker-dealer hub and states page list the profiles.

Sources