The Paper Trail
The Paper TrailFind a Firm

Broker-dealer

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. logo

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.

Broker-dealer · Sausalito, California · CRD 10489 · SEC file no. 8-27639 · CIK 0000702007

View regulator record

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. is a broker-dealer headquartered in Sausalito, California. It is a retail-focused broker-dealer registered with FINRA since 1982, with net capital of $6.5 million and 2 disclosure events of its own in its BrokerCheck and regulator records. The Paper Trail scores it 98 out of 100 with medium confidence, higher than 64% of the 258 rated broker-dealers that are ranked. Figures are as of .

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. was formerly known as Caldwell Securities, Inc. It is also known as Caldwell Securities, Inc and Caldwell Securities, Incorporated.

Client focus
Retail
Net capital
$6.5 million
Disclosure events on BrokerCheck
1
Branch offices
13
The Paper Trail rating
98/100
Among rated broker-dealers
Higher than 64%

Data as of , last read ; 2 sources (SEC Form ADV bulk data file; SEC litigation releases and administrative proceedings) re-checked with no change. Each fact below carries its own source and as-of date. Information, not investment advice.

How does The Paper Trail rate Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. scores 98 out of 100 as a broker-dealer, with medium confidence, as of : higher than 64% of the 258 rated broker-dealers that are ranked. 5 of 5 factors had enough evidence to score. 4 factors share the highest score, 10.0 of 10; the lowest is regulatory record (9.5 of 10).

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s score combines regulatory record (35%), legal record (10%), customer dispute record (15%), financial condition (30%) and operating history (10%). It is not advice, not a rating of service, and it never rates individual representatives.

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. was scored on 100% of the rubric's weight. Every factor in the rubric was scored.

Score factors for Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer
FactorWeightScore (0-10)Basis
Regulatory record35%9.5BrokerCheck lists 1 final regulatory action against the firm, the most recent in 2010, 0 of them in the last five years, with fines totaling $1,000. The score counts recent and serious actions more heavily and scales for firm size (the firm has 13 branch offices on BrokerCheck; registered-representative counts are not published in these records).
Customer dispute record15%10.0BrokerCheck lists no FINRA arbitration awards against this firm; settled cases are not public.
Financial condition30%10.0The firm's audited annual report for the year ended September 30, 2025 states net capital of $6,457,985 against a required minimum of $1,116,986, or 5.8 times the requirement.
Operating history10%10.0The firm has been registered with FINRA since , about 44 years.
Notes on how each factor was computed
  • Operating history: registered with FINRA 44.5 years (since )

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s score as a broker-dealer runs 0 to 100 and is computed from the factors above (a weighted mean of the scored factors, with N/A factors excluded). Missing data is never counted as good or bad; pending matters are shown but never scored; individuals are never rated.

Source: The Paper Trail's scoring under the written rubric for broker-dealers (/broker-dealers/methodology), from the sourced facts on this page; as of .

How does The Paper Trail rate Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. has no published score as an investment adviser: this is a profile without a score. 3 of the 8 factors can be scored for this firm (Regulatory record, Complaint record, Fee transparency), and the adviser method needs 5 of 8 before a rating is published. Cost and Fee transparency come from the firm's Part 2A brochure (read twice, disagreements adjudicated, then blind-checked). Conflicts of interest and Fiduciary standing are not scored at this tier because an independent check found those brochure readings not reliable enough; disclosure consistency is not scored. Client reviews are scored only when the firm has at least 10 public reviews. The profile shows the firm's own Form ADV answers, its disclosure pages, its FINRA BrokerCheck record and the fee facts read from its brochure. Having no score is not a good or a bad mark; the sourced facts below are shown either way.

For Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc., the method would combine client reviews (20%), regulatory record (15%), complaint record (10%), cost (15%), fee transparency (10%), conflicts of interest (15%), disclosure consistency (10%) and fiduciary standing (5%). It is not investment advice and says nothing about future returns.

For Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc., 3 of the 8 factors in the investment adviser method had enough public evidence to check; the table shows each one and what the record holds.

What the investment adviser method could and could not check for Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. (no score is given)
FactorWeightEvidenceWhat the record shows
Client reviews20%Not enoughClient reviews are not scored: no public reviews were found for the firm on its Google business listings, and at least ten are needed.
Regulatory record15%Enough to checkThe firm's Form ADV reports 1 final action against the firm. FINRA BrokerCheck also lists 1 regulatory or civil event disclosure for its broker-dealer record (not scored at this tier).
Complaint record10%Enough to checkNo Better Business Bureau complaint record was found for the firm under its legal, former and trade names; FINRA BrokerCheck lists 0 customer arbitration awards against the broker-dealer, 0 in the last ten years.
Cost15%Not enoughNo cost score is given: the brochure does not publish a fee that can be turned into a rate on $1 million.
Fee transparency10%Enough to checkFee transparency: no fee rate is published.
Conflicts of interest15%Not enoughConflicts of interest are not scored at this tier: an independent check found the automated brochure readings not reliable enough, so this factor is scored only by hand decoding.
Disclosure consistency10%Not enoughDisclosure consistency is not scored here: it is scored only by hand decoding, because reading the documents automatically missed most contradictions between them.
Fiduciary standing5%Not enoughFiduciary standing is not scored at this tier: an independent check found the automated brochure classifications not reliable enough, so it is scored only by hand decoding.

No score is shown for Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser, and none is implied; a missing score is never counted as good or bad. Pending matters are shown but never scored, and individuals are never rated.

Source: The Paper Trail's review under the written rubric for investment advisers (/investment-advisers/methodology), from the sourced facts on this page; as of .

What do public records say about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s public records show a retail client focus, net capital of $6.5 million and 1 disclosure event on BrokerCheck. They are among 16 sourced facts listed here as of . Each row gives its source, the exact quote or value read, and the date the source value is as of.

Key facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer, with sources
FactValueSourceAs of
BrokerCheck firm statusACTIVE · Approved · since brokercheck.finra.orgReported on BrokerCheck: ACTIVE; Approved; 05/19/1982
FINRA firm size classSmallbrokercheck.finra.orgReported on BrokerCheck: Small
Branch offices on BrokerCheck13brokercheck.finra.orgReported on BrokerCheck: 13
Registered with FINRA sincebrokercheck.finra.org“FINRA Approved 05/19/1982”
Form CRS on file with BrokerCheckForm CRS filed by a dually registered firm (broker-dealer and investment adviser)brokercheck.finra.orgValue as filed: DU
BrokerCheck disclosure counts by typeRegulatory Event: 1brokercheck.finra.orgReported on BrokerCheck: Regulatory Event; 1
Holds funds or securities or clears for other broker-dealersNobrokercheck.finra.org“This firm does not hold or maintain funds or securities or provide clearing services for other broker-dealer[s]”
Refers or introduces customers to other brokers and dealersYesbrokercheck.finra.org“This firm does refer or introduce customers to other brokers and dealers”
Net capital (annual audited report)$6.5 millionsec.govValue as filed: net capital was $6,457,985 which exceeded the requirement by $5,340,999. 14. Subsequent Events The Company has evaluated subsequent
Minimum net capital required (annual audited report)$1.1 millionsec.govValue as filed: net capital was $6,457,985 which exceeded the requirement by $5,340,999. 14. Subsequent Events The Company has evaluated subsequent
Independent accountant named on the annual report cover pageErnst Wintter & Associatessec.govValue as filed: Ernst Wintter & Associates
Material weakness reported on the annual report cover pageNosec.govAs filed: No
Going-concern doubt language in the annual reportNosec.gov“No going-concern doubt stated: the report text has no sentence saying there is substantial doubt about the firm's ability to continue as a going concern”
Latest annual audited report filed electronically on EDGARX-17A-5, period ending , filed sec.govListed in this register as: 0000702007-25-000011; ;
All other sourced facts (2)

The other 2 sourced facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer, as of , each with its source and date.

Other sourced facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer
FactValueSourceAs of
Types of business (BrokerCheck)Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; Mutual fund retailer; U S. government securities broker; Municipal securities dealer; Municipal securities broker; Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities; Solicitor of time deposits in a financial institution; Investment advisory services; Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member; Trading securities for own account; Private placements of securities; Other - CALDWELL SUTTER CAPITAL ALSO ENGAGES IN UNDERWRITING OR ACTING AS A SELLING GROUP PARTICIPANT IN PUBLIC OFFERINGS OF MUNICIPAL LISTED SECURITIES ON EITHER A BEST EFFORTS OR FIRM COMMITMENT BASIS.brokercheck.finra.orgValue as filed: Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; Mutual fund retailer; U S. government securities broker; Municipal securities dealer; Municipal securities broker; Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities; Solicitor of time deposits in a financial institution; Investment advisory services; Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member; Trading securities for own account; Private placements of securities; Other - CALDWELL SUTTER CAPITAL ALSO ENGAGES IN UNDERWRITING OR ACTING AS A SELLING GROUP PARTICIPANT IN PUBLIC OFFERINGS OF MUNICIPAL LISTED SECURITIES ON EITHER A BEST EFFORTS OR FIRM COMMITMENT BASIS.
Audit report states the statements present fairly, in all material respectsYessec.gov“presents fairly, in all material respects”

What do public records say about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s public records show registration as an SEC-registered investment adviser and disciplinary items reported on Form ADV. They are among 69 sourced facts listed here as of . Each row gives its source, the exact quote or value read, and the date the source value is as of.

Key facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser, with sources
FactValueSourceAs of
Registration type (SEC-registered investment adviser)SEC-registered investment adviseradviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: Registered; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Date of the firm's latest Form ADV filingadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: latest ADV filing date: 04/17/2026; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Months between the latest Form ADV filing and the review date ()6.8 monthsadviserinfo.sec.gov“ to ”; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Firm reports any regulatory, criminal or civil disciplinary event (Item 11, lead question or any sub-question)Yesadviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed: Form ADV Item 11 (any disciplinary event): No; sub-questions answered Yes: 11D(2); read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Item 11 sub-questions answered Yes11D(2)adviserinfo.sec.gov“Item 11.D(2): Yes (1 disclosure counted by the SEC file)”; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
All other sourced facts (64)

The other 64 sourced facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser, as of , each with its source and date.

Other sourced facts about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser
FactValueSourceAs of
SEC registration statusApprovedadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: SEC current status: Approved; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Date the SEC registration status took effectadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: SEC status effective date: 02/08/2006; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Version of Form ADV the latest filing used10/2021adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: form version: 10/2021; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Legal form of the firm (Item 3.A)Corporationadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: Corporation; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Offices other than the principal office (Item 1.F)2adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 2; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Umbrella registration (the filing covers relying advisers)No (the filing does not cover relying advisers)adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed: umbrella registration: No; total number of relying advisers: left blank; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Website address listed in Form ADV Item 1.IHTTP://WWW.CALD.COM/adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: website address: HTTP://WWW.CALD.COM/; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Employees (Item 5.A) and employees by role (Item 5.B)17 employees; 5 do investment advisory work; 14 are registered representatives of a broker-dealer; 5 are registered with a state as adviser representatives; 0 are licensed insurance agents; 2 are licensed agents of an insurance company related to the firm; 0 people outside the firm soliciting clients for it.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Clients and regulatory assets under management by client type (Item 5.D)individuals (other than high-net-worth): 381 clients, $154 million; high-net-worth individuals: 147 clients, $425 million; pension and profit-sharing plans: 7 clients, $3.5 million; charitable organizations: no client count given, $546,084; corporations or other businesses: 11 clients, $22.7 millionadviserinfo.sec.gov“Item 5.D row (a) individuals (other than high-net-worth): 381 clients, $153,909,207 regulatory assets; row (b) high-net-worth individuals: 147 clients, $425,020,062 regulatory assets; row (g) pension and profit-sharing plans: 7 clients, $3,521,965 regulatory assets; row (h) charitable organizations: fewer than 5 clients (the form's box; no count), $546,084 regulatory assets; row (m) corporations or other businesses: 11 clients, $22,678,032 regulatory assets”; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Individual clients (Item 5.D rows a and b)528adviserinfo.sec.gov“Item 5.D row (a) individuals (other than high-net-worth): 381 clients, $153,909,207 regulatory assets; row (b) high-net-worth individuals: 147 clients, $425,020,062 regulatory assets”; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Clients receiving financial planning (Item 5.H, range)0adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 0; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Regulatory assets under management (Item 5.F.(2)(c))$606 millionadviserinfo.sec.gov“$605,675,350”; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Regulatory assets managed on a discretionary basis (Item 5.F.(2)(a))$575 millionadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 574,731,511.00; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Regulatory assets managed on a non-discretionary basis (Item 5.F.(2)(b))$30.9 millionadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 30,943,839.00; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Accounts under management (Item 5.F.(2)(f))1,249adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 1,249; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
How the firm is paid (Item 5.E)Yes: percentage of assets under management. No to the other 6 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Services offered (Item 5.G)Yes: financial planning; portfolio management for individuals and small businesses. No to the other 10 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Participates in wrap fee programs (Item 5.I.(1))Noadviserinfo.sec.govAs filed: No; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Advertising practices (Item 5.L: performance, testimonials, endorsements, third-party ratings)Yes: performance results in advertising; references to specific investment advice in advertising; predecessor performance in advertising. No to the other 5 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Other business activities (Item 6.A)Yes: broker-dealer; insurance broker or agent; registered municipal advisor. No to the other 11 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Other business or products sold to advisory clients (Item 6.B)No to all 2 items. 1 left blank.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Related persons by type (Item 7.A)No to all 16 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Related-person counts and relationships (Item 7.A summary columns)Advisory affiliates reported: 0; Affiliates that are both adviser and broker-dealer: 0; Broker-dealer affiliates: 0; Controls or is controlled by a related person: No; Under common control: No; Shares supervised persons: Noadviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed: investment adviser affiliates (Form ADV Item 7.A): 0; affiliates that are both adviser and broker-dealer (Form ADV Item 7.A): 0; broker-dealer affiliates (Form ADV Item 7.A): 0; control/controlled by related person: No; under common control: No; share supervised persons: No; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Advises one or more private funds (Item 7.B)Noadviserinfo.sec.govAs filed: No; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Private funds reported in Schedule D 7.B.(1)0adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: count of private funds - 7B(1): 0; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Gross assets of the firm's private funds$0adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: total gross assets of private funds: .00; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Participation or interest in client transactions (Item 8)Yes: buys from or sells to clients as principal; trades for itself in securities it also recommends; recommends securities in which it has another ownership interest; agency cross transactions; decides which securities clients buy or sell; decides the amount clients buy or sell; chooses the broker-dealer for client trades; decides the commission rates clients pay; a broker-dealer it uses is a related person; recommends brokers or dealers to clients; a recommended broker or dealer is a related person. No to the other 6 items. 1 left blank.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Custody of client assets (Item 9.A, 9.B, 9.D)Yes: has custody of clients' cash or bank accounts; has custody of clients' securities. No to the other 4 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Client assets in custody (Item 9.A.(2), 9.B.(2)) and number of qualified custodians (Item 9.F)client assets in its custody: $360 million; 322 clients whose assets it holds; total assets in custody: $360 million; 2 qualified custodians used. 2 left blank.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Custody safeguards (Item 9.C: quarterly statements, pooled-vehicle audit, surprise examination, internal-control report)Yes: an independent accountant makes a surprise examination each year. No to the other 3 items.adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
A person not named elsewhere controls the firm's management or policies (Item 10.A)Noadviserinfo.sec.govAs filed: No; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Item 11 lead question answered (any event involving the firm or its supervised persons)Noadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: Form ADV Item 11 (any disciplinary event): No; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Item 11 reports an event (lead question or a disclosure count) but no sub-question is Yes (nothing to trace)Noadviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed: Form ADV Item 11 (any disciplinary event): No; sub-questions answered Yes: 1; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Number of disclosure events the SEC file counts per Item 11 sub-question (non-zero only)11d(2) 1adviserinfo.sec.govValues as filed on Form ADV Part 1A; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Form ADV PDF with disclosure pages was available and readYesreports.adviserinfo.sec.gov“PDF available”
Disclosure Reporting Pages in the firm's Form ADV (affiliates' names, CRD numbers and narratives are not recorded)1 disclosure page (1 final, 0 pending, 0 other); each is listed, without names, under the regulatory record sectionreports.adviserinfo.sec.gov
Direct owners and executive officers (Schedule A) and indirect owners (Schedule B): counts by type onlySchedule A owners: 9 individuals, 2 domestic entities, 0 foreign entities (11 in all); Schedule B owners: 4 individuals, 0 domestic entities, 0 foreign entities (4 in all)reports.adviserinfo.sec.gov“Schedule A 11 (individuals 9, domestic entities 2, foreign entities 0); Schedule B 4”
Related persons listed in Schedule D 7.A, count and count by type0 related persons; related persons acting as custodian: 0reports.adviserinfo.sec.govCounted from Schedule D, Section 7.A of the firm's Form ADV
Part 2A brochures on file in the SEC's adviser database1adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: 1 brochure listed; the firm does not claim an exemption from filing a Part 2 brochure
States where the SEC database lists a notice filing11adviserinfo.sec.gov
Surprise-examination filings by an independent accountant on record3adviserinfo.sec.gov
FINRA BrokerCheck firm record retrievedYesadviserinfo.sec.gov“firm record found”
Firm is, or controls, a FINRA-member broker-dealer (Form ADV 6.A.(1) = Yes, or an active BrokerCheck broker-dealer record)Yesadviserinfo.sec.govAs filed: Yes; BrokerCheck broker-dealer record: yes, scope ACTIVE
BrokerCheck disclosure summary for the firm, by typeregulatory event 1adviserinfo.sec.gov“Regulatory Event: 1”
Arbitration disclosures BrokerCheck lists for the broker-dealer0adviserinfo.sec.gov
Yearly SEC snapshots (2016-2025) in which the firm appears as a registered adviser10adviserinfo.sec.govComputed from the yearly SEC snapshots: first seen October 2016; months October 2016, October 2017, October 2018, October 2019, October 2020, October 2021, October 2022, October 2023, October 2024, September 2025; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
Legal-name changes across the yearly SEC snapshots, 2016 to 20251adviserinfo.sec.govComputed from the yearly SEC snapshots: Caldwell Securities, Inc. became Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
The firm's Form ADV Part 1 answers on seven kinds of conflict of interest (shown, not scored; the other kinds need the Part 2A brochure)performance fees: no; affiliated broker: no; principal trading: yes; private funds: no; commissions: yes; insurance sales: yes; referral payments: noadviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: performance-based fees: no; affiliated broker-dealer: no; principal or cross trades: yes; private funds: no; commissions: yes; insurance sales: yes; pays for client referrals: no; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
What the firm's Form ADV Part 1 answers say about commissioned sales; shown, not scoredFiduciary when giving advice; the firm or its people also sell commissioned securities or insuranceadviserinfo.sec.govRead from the firm's answers to Form ADV Items 5E(5), 6A(1), 6A(2), 6A(6), 7A(1) and 7A(12); none of them points to commissioned sales; read from the SEC's monthly adviser data file
SEC litigation-release and administrative-proceeding name search ran for this firm (SEC lists read )Yessec.gov“SEC litigation releases and administrative proceedings (1995 to ) searched by 3 name forms on ; 0 name matches”
Mechanical name matches in the SEC lists (none)0sec.gov“none”
Every SEC-list name match has been read against its primary document and decided by a reviewerYes (there was no name match to review)sec.gov“reviewed”
Possible matches on the SEC's lists not confirmed as this firm (never counted as a matter)None listedsec.gov“none”
Every new SEC-list finding was re-checked by a second reviewer (or there was no name match to check)Yessec.gov“second check recorded”
Matters confirmed in SEC records after review (firm-level, resolved or pending)None listed apart from the firm's own Form ADV disclosure pagessec.gov
Part 2A brochure read for this profile (SEC Part 2 bulk files; two independent extractions, disagreements adjudicated)read for its fees (two independent extractions, disagreements adjudicated)reports.adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: the firm's Part 2A brochure from the SEC's monthly brochure files dated
Brochure and Form CRS documents readBrochure (Form ADV Part 2A) dated reports.adviserinfo.sec.govValue as filed: brochure dated
Brochure-tier factors that could not be scored, with the reasonnonereports.adviserinfo.sec.gov
Fields on which the two extractions disagree and the disagreement is unresolvednonereports.adviserinfo.sec.gov
Fee schedule a typical individual client pays (primary schedule from the brochure; two readings agree or were adjudicated)Not disclosedreports.adviserinfo.sec.gov“no fee rate is published”
Annual fee on a $1 million account under the primary schedule (percent of assets)Not disclosedreports.adviserinfo.sec.govComputed: No rate on $1 million can be computed
How completely the brochure publishes its fee scheduleno fee rate is publishedreports.adviserinfo.sec.gov
Public client reviews counted for the firm (Google business listings matched to the firm by its official website and Form ADV offices, with sister businesses and namesakes left out; scored only with at least ten)no public reviews foundgoogle.com“no public reviews found on the firm's Google business listings”
Complaint search: Better Business Bureau (legal, former and trade names with city and state) and, for a FINRA-member firm, the FINRA BrokerCheck report's arbitration awardsBBB: no complaint record found; FINRA BrokerCheck arbitration: 0 awards against the firm, 0 in the last ten yearsbbb.org“BBB searched under 2 names (legal, other and former names) with city and state in 3 searches; no confirmed listing; FINRA BrokerCheck report read: 0 arbitration awards against the firm, 0 in the last ten years”

What lines of business is Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. in?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. reports 13 lines of business on its broker-dealer registration: broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; mutual fund retailer; and 10 more, listed below.

  • Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter
  • Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities
  • Mutual fund retailer
  • U.S. government securities broker
  • Municipal securities dealer
  • Municipal securities broker
  • Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities
  • Solicitor of time deposits in a financial institution
  • Investment advisory services
  • Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member
  • Trading securities for own account
  • Private placements of securities
  • Other - CALDWELL SUTTER CAPITAL ALSO ENGAGES IN UNDERWRITING OR ACTING AS A SELLING GROUP PARTICIPANT IN PUBLIC OFFERINGS OF MUNICIPAL LISTED SECURITIES ON EITHER A BEST EFFORTS OR FIRM COMMITMENT BASIS.

Source: FINRA BrokerCheck (https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/10489); as of .

Is Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. also an investment adviser?

Yes. Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. is also a registered investment adviser (SEC file no. 801-66098), according to its broker-dealer record as of . Its adviser side has not been profiled on The Paper Trail yet, so there is no adviser profile to link to.

How has Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. changed over the years?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s regulatory assets rose from $138 million in 2016 to $571 million in 2025. Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s figures are from the SEC's yearly adviser files, 2016 to 2025, as reported.

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. by year
YearRegulatory assetsIndividual clientsAccounts
2016$138 millionNot reported634
2017$165 millionNot reported522
2018$174 million228462
2019$206 million253499
2020$233 million269523
2021$235 million258525
2022$307 million263536
2023$300 million268559
2024$488 million5231,256
2025$571 million5261,225

Is Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. registered, and who regulates it?

Registration or charter of Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.: broker-dealer. Its regulator: FINRA member firm; registered with the SEC (file 8-27639). Status in the regulator's record: active, approved, since (FINRA approval date, BrokerCheck). CRD number: 10489. Final matters against the firm itself on record: 1 (1 regulatory), dated to ; 1 of them counts in the rating; 0 were resolved in the last five years. Pending matters are listed separately and not counted. Record as of . Where to verify it: FINRA BrokerCheck.

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. also appears in public regulator records as an investment adviser; those registrations are overseen by the SEC and FINRA as a registered broker-dealer; and by the SEC or its state securities regulator as an investment adviser. Appearing in a regulator database is not an endorsement.

What does Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. charge and what is its minimum?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. reports that it charges a percentage of assets under management (Form ADV Part 1, Item 5.E, as of ). It does not report hourly charges, subscription fees, fixed fees, commissions, performance-based fees and other fees. A minimum account size is not stated in the filings read.

Does Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. have a regulatory or legal record?

The records below list 2 matters for Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. Matters concerning the firm itself: 2 final, 0 pending, 0 other. All concern the firm itself. BrokerCheck counts 1 disclosure events for this firm. The matter table shows 2 rows: the 1 firm-level records and 0 control-affiliate records, less 0 second listings of one event (counted once), and 1 more because the table adds matters from the outside record. Pending matters are allegations or unresolved proceedings: they are shown and labeled, and never scored. Individuals are never named or rated.

Regulatory, legal and complaint matters for Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.
DateRegulator or courtMatterConcernsStatusSource
State of MaineRegulatory action; State of Maine: Other (fine and disgorgement of commissions), involving the firm; docket 20-16774; sanction: fine $2,500 on the firm and disgorgement of commissions $3,686.78 (a separate $500 fine was imposed on an individual); resolution: Consent; monetary $2,500; fine $2,500; ref. 20-16774the firm and an individual (name withheld)Finalreports.adviserinfo.sec.govForm ADV disclosure page
Oregon Division of Finance & Corperate SecuritiesRegulatory matter; Consent; Monetary/Fine, Cease and Desist/Injunction; initiated ; fine $1,000; ref. S-10-0029the firmFinalfiles.brokercheck.finra.orgFINRA BrokerCheck report; as filed: Current Status: Final | Initiated By: OREGON DIVISION OF FINANCE & CORPERATE SECURITIES | Date Initiated: 09/08/2010 | Docket/Case Number: S-10-0029 | Resolution: Consent | Resolution Date: 09/08/2010 | Monetary/Fine $1,000.00
How the record was searched (1)
  • The Paper Trail reviewed a search of the SEC's enforcement lists on : it found no name hits and read 2 primary-source pages and no other leads. No matter from this search is listed separately; the search was complete.

How can I check Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. myself?

To check Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. yourself, use FINRA BrokerCheck. Search the firm's name or CRD number, then read its summary, its disclosure events (regulatory, arbitration and civil) and its Form CRS. Search with the identifier shown at the top of this page: CRD 10489 · SEC file no. 8-27639 · CIK 0000702007.

How does Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. compare with other broker-dealers in California?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. ranks 18 of 286 broker-dealers headquartered in California in this dataset by net capital ($6.5 million); size is available for 139 of them.

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. and nearby broker-dealers in California, ordered by net capital
#FirmCityNet capitalScore
16Matthews South, LLCSan Mateo$8.4 million95
17Investment Placement GroupSan Diego$7.0 million87
18Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.Sausalito$6.5 million98
19CMG Securities LLCSan Ramon$6.3 million95
20Eastdil Secured Advisors LLCSanta Monica$5.7 million95

How is the score calculated?

Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. is assessed under the written rubric for its firm type. A factor is scored 0 to 10 from sourced facts, each factor has a published weight, factors without enough evidence are excluded and the rest are re-weighted, and a score is published only when the rubric's publication gate is met and the record's facts have been checked a second time (how Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc.'s facts were checked is under "Where does this information come from?").

Where does this information come from?

The 85 fact rows about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. in the tables above come from 6 public sources. The source values are dated to . The day each source was read for this firm is listed below. Nothing here comes from the firm's marketing unless a fact says so, and each fact's source and exact quote are in its row. Second check: 17 underlying values behind the 16 fact rows about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer were read again from the original sources in a second, separate pass on ; 1 difference found was resolved, and none is left open. 125 underlying values behind the 69 fact rows about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser were recomputed from the regulator's data files by a second, separately written program on , and they matched.

Together, the 85 fact rows about Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. come from:

For Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as a broker-dealer, the 16 fact rows come from:

For Caldwell Sutter Capital, Inc. as an investment adviser, 69 fact rows in that section's tables come from:

  • SEC Form ADV bulk data file, read ; re-checked with no change (43 facts)
  • FINRA BrokerCheck, read (14 facts)
  • SEC litigation releases and administrative proceedings, read ; re-checked with no change (12 facts)
  • Form ADV PDF (SEC adviser database), read (11 facts)
  • SEC adviser database (IAPD) record, read (3 facts)
  • SEC EDGAR annual audited report (Form X-17A-5), read (1 fact)
  • www.bbb.org, read (1 fact)
  • www.google.com, read (1 fact)