Methodology
How Adviser Profiles Without a Rating Work
The Paper Trail has 1,350 adviser-only profiles without a rating, built from public filings and, for 1,341 of them, the fees in the firm's brochure. 230 other advisers have five scored factors and are rated from filings and federal records. Unrated profiles carry no score: the adviser method (version 2.7) needs at least 5 of 8 factors scored. Most recent data: . Information, not investment advice.
How firms are shown when the full hand-decoding has not been done (the record tier)
The Paper Trail rates an investment adviser only when enough of the firm's record can be scored: at least 5 of 8 factors, at least one factor that rests on records the firm does not write itself, and a confidence level of Medium or higher. The full method, with every weight and rule, is the adviser scoring method (the adviser scoring method, version 2.7) and applies here unchanged.
This page covers the firms profiled from public filings and federal records without a hand-decoded reading of every document. We call this the record tier. A record-tier profile is rated when five of its factors can be scored and shown as not rated when fewer can: it shows facts, the facts are checked, and no overall number is given.
What does a profile without a rating use?
- The firm's own Form ADV Part 1 answers as published by the SEC (employees, clients, assets under management, how the firm is paid, other businesses, related firms, custody, and the disciplinary questions in Item 11).
- The firm's Form ADV disclosure pages, where it reports a disciplinary event.
- The SEC's adviser database and FINRA BrokerCheck records for the firm.
- A name search of SEC litigation releases and administrative proceedings, with each match read against the original order before it is used.
- The fee schedule in the firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, read twice by independent readers.
- Client reviews from Google business listings, and a recorded Better Business Bureau complaint search.
What is scored, and what is not?
| Factor | Weight in the full method | At the record tier |
|---|---|---|
| Client reviews | 20 | Scored with at least 10 counted reviews (Google business listings matched by the firm's official website and Form ADV offices); fewer than 10 is not scored |
| Regulatory record | 15 | Scored when the firm's disciplinary answers and disclosure pages can be fully read |
| Complaint record | 10 | Scored when a complete recorded search was run: a search that finds nothing scores 10; a possible listing that cannot be matched to the firm leaves the factor not scored |
| Cost | 15 | Scored for the 1,202 advisers whose brochure fee schedule gives a fee on a $1 million account; not scored for the others |
| Fee transparency | 10 | Scored for the 1,697 advisers whose brochure fee schedule was read; not scored for the others |
| Conflicts of interest | 15 | Not scored: scored only from the brochure |
| Disclosure consistency | 10 | Not scored: compares the brochure, Form CRS and Form ADV |
| Fiduciary standing | 5 | Not scored: scored only from the brochure |
The firm's own Form ADV Part 1 answers on seven kinds of conflict (performance fees, a related broker-dealer, principal trading, private funds, commissions, insurance sales, paying for referrals) and on commissioned sales are shown as facts, labelled as the firm's own answers. They are not turned into a score, because the other kinds of conflict can only be read from the brochure and a partial reading would flatter firms.
Of the 1,350 advisers profiled without a rating, 1,341 had their latest Part 2A brochure read for its fees, twice by independent readers with differences settled from the source page: 1,197 of those profiles show a fee schedule and 858 show a fee on a $1 million account. The fee readings give a Fee transparency score to 1,318 of them and a Cost score to 858, but a rating needs at least 5 of the 8 factors scored and none has more than 4 of the 8, so none is rated. Client reviews are scored only for a firm with at least 10 public reviews, disclosure consistency is not collected, and conflicts of interest and fiduciary standing are not scored: a blind check of the brochure readings found 20 differences in 228 fields, or 8.77%, above the 1% limit for a published fact. 230 other advisers reached five scored factors and are rated from filings and federal records, at Medium confidence at most. These are the adviser-only profiles: counting the 1 hand-decoded adviser whose rating is held, 1,351 advisers have no published rating.
How is the regulatory record read for these profiles?
The factor starts at 10. A resolved action against the firm itself lowers it by 3.0 if resolved within 5 years, 1.5 if 5 to 10 years ago and 0.5 if older, and by a further 1.0 for a sanction of $250,000 or more. Actions that involve only an individual who works for the firm are shown, never scored. Pending matters are shown, never scored. A firm that answers No to every Item 11 question is scored 10 on its own filing, which is not counted as an outside record. When the firm reports an event, the factor is scored only if every Yes answer can be matched to its disclosure page; otherwise it is left unscored and the reason is stated. Confirmed SEC actions found in the name search, and not already in the firm's Form ADV, are added with the same schedule.
How can a firm get a rating?
A firm moves from not rated to rated when its fifth factor can be scored, most often when it has at least 10 counted client reviews. A rated record-tier firm carries confidence no higher than Medium. The firms researched by hand keep their own method: the adviser scoring method, version 2.7.
What does the brochure add, and what does it leave unscored?
The profile shows what the firm's Part 2A brochure says about its fees: the fee schedule a typical individual client pays, the fee on a $1 million account and how it charges. Other brochure readings (the other programs a brochure prices, its minimum fee or account size, and the firm's own statement of its duty to clients) failed their independent blind check and are not shown.
Two things the brochure could be used to score are not scored: conflicts of interest and fiduciary standing. An independent check of the automated brochure readings found them not reliable enough (the conflict calls disagreed in about 13 of every 100 cases, against the limit of 1 in 100 items for a reading to be shown as a fact; the hand-decoded tier's own bar, under 2 in 100 fields, is in the adviser scoring method, version 2.7), so those two factors are scored only where a person decoded the firm's documents. Disclosure consistency is not collected at this tier. Cost, fee transparency and client reviews are scored, so a firm with at least 10 counted reviews reaches five scored factors and is rated. A firm without them has at most four and is shown as not rated.
The fee schedule in each adviser’s Form ADV Part 2A brochure is read by two independent readers (1,718 advisers). Every disagreement is settled from the source page, and every figure is stored with its quote and its page. The readings give 1,202 advisers a Cost score and 1,697 a Fee transparency score. Two written rules keep every reading the same.
- Rule D2, tier method: a schedule is blended (each band is charged at its own rate) or whole-account (one rate applies to the whole amount); the brochure’s worked example decides first, then its wording, and a schedule the brochure does not settle is marked unknown and gets no dollar figure.
- Rule D14, primary schedule: when a brochure prices several asset-based schedules, the primary schedule is the one the brochure calls standard or typical, otherwise the schedule of the firm’s main portfolio management service for individual clients when exactly one fits; if more than one fits equally, there is no primary schedule and Cost is not scored.
An independent blind re-read of a random sample matched 96.7% of fee-schedule fields (772 of 798). The sample covered 448 fields of firms read in this round (431 matched, 96.2%) and 350 fields of firms published earlier (341 matched, 97.4%). Every fee fact on a firm's page shows its quote and its page. An earlier, smaller blind check of the same fee schedule readings found 1 difference in 70 fields (1.43%) in its sample and no difference in 56 fields of firms checked again; pooled, 1 in 126 (0.79%), under the 1% bar.
How complete are the fields on these profiles?
For each field, how many of the 1,729 investment adviser profiles carry a value; how many have the source read and the field blank or not reported there ("not disclosed in the source"); and how many have no such fact at all ("not collected").
Field completeness, 1,729 investment adviser profiles
| Field | Present | Not disclosed in the source | Not collected |
|---|---|---|---|
| Name | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| City | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| State | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| CRD | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Regulatory assets under management | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Individual clients | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Item 11 disciplinary answers | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Latest Form ADV filing date | 1,729 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
This page is the written rubric the rating program follows, with file names and internal codes put in words. Individuals are never rated, pending matters and allegations are shown but never scored, and missing data is never counted as good or bad. Information, not investment advice.