Which registration and background questions does the SEC suggest asking?
The SEC suggests asking a financial adviser whether the person is registered with the SEC, a state securities regulator or FINRA; whether the person has been disciplined by a regulator or had customer complaints; and what experience and related education the person has. The SEC says to check both the person and the firm, and the answers can be compared with the public registration records.
- Are you registered with the SEC, a state securities regulator, or FINRA?
- Have you ever been disciplined by a regulator? If yes, what was the problem and how was it resolved?
- Have you had customer complaints? If yes, how many, what were they about, and how were they resolved?
- What experience do you have, especially with people like me?
- What education have you had that relates to your work? How long have you done this type of work?
The sources for these checks are the SEC's Investor.gov page on investment advisers. Registration, employment history and disciplinary disclosures appear on the SEC's adviser database and FINRA's BrokerCheck; state securities regulators can be found through NASAA.
On professional designations, an SEC investor bulletin notes that they are titles given by industry groups that are not regulated or subject to standards other than their own. A firm's brochure supplement must explain the minimum qualifications for any designation it lists for an individual, under Form ADV Part 2B.
Which questions about services does the SEC suggest asking?
The SEC's suggested questions about an adviser's services ask whether an advisory service, a brokerage service or both fits the investor's situation, what products and services the professional offers and whether the menu is limited, how investments will be chosen, how often the account will be reviewed and who makes investment decisions, and who the primary contact is.
- Given my financial situation, should I choose an investment advisory service, a brokerage service, or both? Why or why not?
- What products and services do you offer? Are you only supposed to recommend a limited number of products to me? If so, why?
- How will you choose investments to recommend to me?
- How often will you review my account? Who will make investment decisions for it?
- Who is my primary contact person, and who can I talk to if I have concerns about how this person is treating me?
Several of these services questions are conversation starters the SEC requires in Form CRS, and others come from the SEC's bulletin on opening an advisory account. Form CRS must say whether the firm monitors investments and how often, whether it offers only its own products or a limited menu, and whether it has account minimums.
Which questions about fees and pay does the SEC suggest asking?
The SEC's suggested questions about an adviser's fees and pay ask how the professional gets paid, how much of a $10,000 investment would go to fees and costs, what all the account's fees are and whether a fee schedule lists them, which fees are paid directly and which are taken from products, whether someone else such as a fund company pays the professional, and how much an investment must rise to break even.
- How do you get paid?
- If I give you $10,000 to invest, how much will go to fees and costs, and how much will be invested for me?
- What are all the fees relating to this account? Do you have a fee schedule that lists all of the fees?
- Which fees will I pay directly, and which are taken from the products I own?
- Does someone else (such as a fund company) pay you for offering or selling these products or services?
- How much does this investment have to increase in value before I break even?
The fees and pay questions above appear on the SEC's Investor.gov pages on investment advisers and fees, in the SEC's fee bulletin, in its list of key questions for hiring a financial professional and among the Form CRS conversation starters. The answers can be compared with Item 5 of the firm's Form ADV brochure, which must give the fee schedule, say whether fees are negotiable and describe other costs such as custodian fees and fund expenses.
Which questions about the standard of conduct and conflicts does the SEC suggest asking?
The SEC's suggested questions on an adviser's standard of conduct and conflicts ask what legal obligations the professional has when providing recommendations as a broker-dealer or when acting as an investment adviser, how conflicts of interest might affect the investor and how they will be addressed, whether the firm offers "house" products with selling incentives, and whether the contact represents an investment adviser or a broker-dealer.
- What are your legal obligations to me when providing recommendations as my broker-dealer or when acting as my investment adviser?
- How might your conflicts of interest affect me, and how will you address them?
- Do you offer "house" products, and do you receive incentives for selling them?
- Is my contact a representative of an investment adviser or a broker-dealer?
Advisers must act in a client's best interest and not put their own interest ahead of the client's, and brokers must do so when making a recommendation, the SEC explains in its materials for advisers and brokers. For professionals who offer both kinds of accounts, the SEC says it is important to understand when they are acting as a broker and when as an adviser.
A firm's Form CRS must state its standard of conduct in required wording and summarize conflicts such as proprietary products, third-party payments and revenue sharing. More detail is in the Form ADV brochure, including Items 5, 10, 11, 12 and 14.
What does the SEC say to understand in an advisory contract?
Most investment advisers ask clients to sign a written advisory contract, according to the SEC's bulletin on opening an advisory account. It lists items to understand in that contract: the services and how often they are provided, the products offered, how fees are calculated, the client's responsibilities, how to contact the adviser, how to cancel, the adviser's conflicts and how they are managed, and the remedies available if the client is unhappy.
Which documents can you request before hiring an adviser?
The documents a reader can request before hiring an adviser are Form CRS, the relationship summary; Form ADV Part 2A, the firm brochure; Form ADV Part 2B, the brochure supplement for each person who will advise the account; and the advisory or account agreement itself. Form CRS must be delivered at or before the start of the relationship and within 30 days of a request.
- Form CRS, the relationship summary, which must be delivered at or before the start of the relationship and within 30 days of a request.
- Form ADV Part 2A, the firm brochure, delivered before or at the time an advisory agreement is entered into.
- Form ADV Part 2B, the brochure supplement for each person who will advise the account.
- The advisory or account agreement itself.
If a professional does not appear in the public databases, the SEC notes it may mean the person is not registered, and suggests contacting the state securities regulator. The SEC's help line is (800) 732-0330.
What are 8 questions to ask a financial advisor?
Eight questions drawn from the SEC's question lists cover registration, discipline, experience, how investments are chosen, how the professional is paid, what $10,000 would cost in fees and conflicts of interest. Each answer can be checked against the public registration databases or against the Form ADV brochure and Form CRS the firm must provide, as the sections above show.
- Are you registered with the SEC, a state securities regulator, or FINRA?
- Have you ever been disciplined by a regulator? If yes, what was the problem and how was it resolved?
- What experience do you have, especially with people like me?
- How will you choose investments to recommend to me?
- How do you get paid?
- If I give you $10,000 to invest, how much will go to fees and costs, and how much will be invested for me?
- Does someone else (such as a fund company) pay you for offering or selling these products or services?
- How might your conflicts of interest affect me, and how will you address them?
What are the top 10 questions to ask a financial advisor?
Ten questions from the SEC's question lists extend the eight above with two on the professional's legal obligations and the primary contact person. Together they cover registration, discipline, experience, investment selection, pay, fees, conflicts, the standard of conduct and who to call with concerns, and each can be checked against the firm's Form ADV brochure and Form CRS.
- Are you registered with the SEC, a state securities regulator, or FINRA?
- Have you ever been disciplined by a regulator? If yes, what was the problem and how was it resolved?
- What experience do you have, especially with people like me?
- How will you choose investments to recommend to me?
- How do you get paid?
- If I give you $10,000 to invest, how much will go to fees and costs, and how much will be invested for me?
- Does someone else (such as a fund company) pay you for offering or selling these products or services?
- How might your conflicts of interest affect me, and how will you address them?
- What are your legal obligations to me when providing recommendations as my broker-dealer or when acting as my investment adviser?
- Who is my primary contact person, and who can I talk to if I have concerns about how this person is treating me?
What do you talk to a financial advisor about?
A first conversation with a financial advisor can cover the topics the SEC's Form CRS conversation starters name: which kind of service fits the investor's situation, how investments will be chosen, the professional's experience and qualifications, how fees and costs would affect the investments, conflicts of interest, disciplinary history and who the primary contact is. Form ADV Part 1A, Item 5.G lists services an adviser may provide, such as financial planning and portfolio management.
Some topics are answered in documents before the meeting: Form ADV Part 2A, Item 4 describes the services offered, and Item 7 describes the kinds of clients the firm serves and any requirement to open or keep an account, such as a minimum account size.
How do you find a reliable, honest or trustworthy financial advisor?
A reader finds financial advisors to check by starting from the public registers and a directory, then verifying each name: the SEC's IAPD covers SEC-registered and most state-registered advisory firms and their representatives, FINRA's BrokerCheck covers brokers and brokerage firms, and NASAA lists state securities regulators. The Paper Trail's adviser directory lists West advisers by state and city. No source read says which adviser is reliable, honest or trustworthy.
FINRA's BrokerCheck FAQ says FINRA does not publish a list of registered investment professionals, but individual professionals can be looked up through BrokerCheck, so a name has to come first. Once a name is in hand, the checks in this guide apply: registration, disciplinary history, how the person is paid, and the Form ADV brochure and Form CRS.
Sources
- BrokerCheck FAQ (FINRA)
- Investment Advisers, Brokers and Understanding Fees pages (SEC, published on Investor.gov)
- Investor Bulletin: Opening an Investment Advisory Account (SEC, published on Investor.gov)
- Investor Bulletin: Top Tips for Selecting a Financial Professional (SEC)
- Investor Bulletin: How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio (SEC)
- Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest: A Small Entity Compliance Guide (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest, Form CRS and related interpretations (SEC)
- Form CRS instructions (SEC)
- Form ADV Part 2 instructions (SEC)
- Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (SEC)
- BrokerCheck (FINRA)
- Contact Your Regulator (NASAA)