What assumptions does the 1% fee example use?
The 1% fee-cost figures in this guide are illustrations, not projections, and rest on simple, stated assumptions: a one-time deposit of $500,000 or $1,000,000 with no further deposits or withdrawals, a steady 6% return every year before fees, a flat fee of 1% of the account's value charged once a year after that year's growth, and no taxes, trading costs or fund expenses. In full:
- A one-time deposit of $500,000 or $1,000,000, with no further deposits or withdrawals.
- A steady 6% return every year before fees. Real returns vary from year to year, and losses happen.
- A flat fee of 1% of the account's value, charged once a year at the end of the year, after that year's growth.
- No taxes, trading costs or fund expenses. Those would reduce both columns.
- Results rounded to the nearest dollar.
In formula terms, the account with no fee grows by a factor of 1.06 each year. The account with the fee grows by 1.06 and then keeps 99% of the result, a factor of 1.0494 a year. "Fees paid" adds up each year's 1% charge.
| Starting balance | Years | No fee | With 1% fee | Difference | Total fees paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500,000 | 10 | $895,424 | $809,805 | $85,619 | $66,476 |
| $500,000 | 20 | $1,603,568 | $1,311,569 | $291,999 | $174,142 |
| $1,000,000 | 10 | $1,790,848 | $1,619,611 | $171,237 | $132,953 |
| $1,000,000 | 20 | $3,207,135 | $2,623,138 | $583,997 | $348,285 |
Why does the gap outgrow the fees paid?
On the $1 million account, the 1% fees charged over 20 years add up to about $348,000. The account ends about $584,000 behind. The extra $236,000 is the growth the fee dollars would have earned had they stayed in the account.
The SEC makes the same point in an investor bulletin on fees: with an ongoing fee, the balance is reduced by the fee and the investor also loses the return that would have been earned on it. Because an asset-based fee is a percentage, the dollar amount rises as the account grows.
How do smaller advisory fees compare?
The 1% fee method applied to smaller fees on the $1 million account, again over 20 years at 6% before fees, shows the same pattern at a smaller scale: a 0.25% annual fee ends at $3,050,531, or $156,605 less than with no fee, and a 0.50% fee ends at $2,901,208, or $305,927 less, compared with $2,623,138 and $583,997 less at 1.00%:
| Annual fee | Ending balance | Difference from no fee | Total fees paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | $3,207,135 | — | — |
| 0.25% | $3,050,531 | $156,605 | $94,750 |
| 0.50% | $2,901,208 | $305,927 | $184,212 |
| 1.00% | $2,623,138 | $583,997 | $348,285 |
Does this method match the SEC's own fee example?
The SEC shows a $100,000 investment growing 4% a year for 20 years. It says the account would be worth about $208,000 with a 0.25% annual fee, about $198,000 with 0.50% and about $179,000 with 1%. The fee method used in this guide reproduces those figures: $208,413, $198,211 and $179,213.
What does the 1% fee example leave out?
Real accounts differ from this 1% fee illustration in several ways. Asset-based fees may be charged annually, quarterly or monthly, according to an SEC investor bulletin on margin accounts, and sometimes in advance; an adviser's Form ADV brochure must say how often fees are charged, whether they are deducted from the account or billed, and whether they are negotiable.
The advisory fee is also rarely the only cost. The brochure must describe other fees clients may pay, such as custodian fees and mutual fund expenses, and say that brokerage and other transaction costs apply. Funds charge their own annual operating expenses, which can include management fees and 12b-1 fees, according to the SEC's fee bulletin.
The advisory fee also pays for services, and the illustration assumes the same return with and without an adviser. Whether the services are worth the cost is a separate question these numbers do not answer.
How can you run the numbers on a real fee?
A firm's Form CRS must include a question investors can ask: "If I give you $10,000 to invest, how much will go to fees and costs, and how much will be invested for me?" It must also state that fees and costs are paid whether the investor makes or loses money.
For a quick estimate with a different fee or return, the yearly factor is (1 + return) × (1 − fee). Raising that factor to the number of years and multiplying by the starting balance gives the ending value under the same assumptions used here. The SEC's Investor.gov site also offers a compound interest calculator.
Sources
- Investor Bulletin: How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio (SEC)
- Investor Bulletin: Understanding Margin Accounts (SEC, published on Investor.gov)
- Form ADV Part 2 instructions, Item 5 (SEC)
- Form CRS instructions, Item 3 (SEC)