Neither "fee-only" nor "fee-based" appears in the text of Form ADV Part 1A, Part 2 or the Form ADV instructions that The Paper Trail read, so neither has a regulatory definition there. Those forms instead require firms to describe how they and their people are actually paid, and those descriptions can be compared with any label a firm uses.
What is commission pay?
A broker is typically paid a commission or markup each time a client buys or sells an investment, according to the SEC. The SEC's fee bulletin lists other transaction-based charges, including sales loads on some mutual funds and surrender charges on variable annuities, which it says compensate the professional for the sale.
The Form CRS instructions give brokers an example of how to describe the conflict: an investor is charged more when there are more trades, so the firm may have an incentive to encourage frequent trading.
What is fee pay for an investment adviser?
An investment adviser is typically paid an ongoing asset-based fee based on the total value of the account, the SEC says. Client fees may also be hourly, fixed or flat, according to an SEC bulletin on opening an advisory account. Form ADV Part 1A asks advisers to check every way they are paid for advice: a percentage of assets under management, hourly charges, subscription fees, fixed fees, commissions, performance-based fees or other.
Asset-based fees carry their own incentive. The Form CRS instructions suggest that an adviser charging an asset-based fee could explain that the more assets in the account, the more the client pays, giving the firm an incentive to encourage adding assets.
Where does the term "fee-based" come from?
The SEC's investor site uses "fee-based accounts" for accounts that charge an asset-based fee, annually, quarterly or monthly, instead of charging for individual transactions, in a bulletin on margin accounts. The SEC's 2019 adviser interpretation likewise contrasts "a commission-based brokerage account" with "a fee-based advisory account."
Describing an account as fee-based does not describe all of a professional's income. Many firms are registered as both brokers and advisers, and their professionals may offer both kinds of accounts.
Why do the fee-only, fee-based and commission labels blur?
Pay often comes from more than one source. Advisers commonly earn money through client fees, commissions or a combination of the two, according to the SEC's bulletin on opening an advisory account. Form ADV Part 1A asks whether the advisory firm is also in business as a broker-dealer, a broker's registered representative, an insurance broker or agent, or another financial product salesperson.
Some adviser and broker pay is indirect. An SEC investor bulletin on choosing a professional notes that even when an investor does not pay the professional directly, someone else may be paying for selling specific products, and those payments may be built into the costs the investor ultimately pays. 12b-1 fees, which a mutual fund pays out of its assets partly to compensate those who sell its shares, are one example.
Titles add to the confusion. Under Regulation Best Interest, the SEC presumes a broker-dealer that is not also a registered adviser, or a representative who is not also a supervised person of an adviser, violates the rule's disclosure requirement by using "adviser" or "advisor" in a name or title, according to SEC staff FAQs. The staff says generic materials at dually registered firms that call their professionals "financial advisors" do not, by themselves, presumptively violate the rule, though additional disclosure of capacity may be needed when a recommendation is made.
What do the regulatory forms require instead of labels?
Instead of labels, Form ADV and Form CRS require firms to disclose sales-based pay and the conflict it creates (Form ADV Part 2A, Item 5.E), each individual's sales-based pay (Part 2B, Item 4), any broker-dealer registration (Part 2A, Item 10) and how financial professionals make money (Form CRS). A claim that a firm is paid only by its clients can be checked against these required disclosures:
- Form ADV Part 2A, Item 5.E (instructions): if the firm or its people accept pay for selling securities or other investment products, the brochure must say so and call it a conflict of interest. If more than half the firm's revenue from advisory clients comes from such sales, it must say commissions are its primary, or exclusive, compensation. If it charges advisory fees on top of commissions, it must say whether it reduces the fees to offset them.
- Form ADV Part 2B, Item 4: the supplement for each individual must disclose commissions, bonuses or other sales-based pay, including mutual fund "trail" fees, and explain the incentive this creates.
- Form ADV Part 2A, Item 10: whether the firm or its managers are registered as a broker-dealer or a broker's representative.
- Form CRS: a required section titled "How do your financial professionals make money?" covering whether pay depends on assets serviced, the time and complexity of a client's needs, the product sold, commissions or the firm's revenue from their advice.
Which costs less, commission pay or fee pay?
Neither commission pay nor fee pay is cheaper in every case. The SEC says a transaction-based fee may suit someone who does not trade often or plans to hold investments for long periods, while an asset-based fee may cost more but may suit someone who wants ongoing advice or wants someone else to make investment decisions.
The Form CRS conversation starters include a direct way to compare: asking how much of a $10,000 investment would go to fees and costs, and how much would be invested.
Why do financial advisors push annuities?
Whether a particular professional pushes annuities cannot be read from the public record, but the record shows what can create an incentive: pay tied to the sale. FINRA lists surrender charges on early withdrawal from a variable annuity among transaction costs, and Form ADV Part 2A, Item 5.E requires an adviser whose people accept pay for selling investment products to disclose a conflict of interest and an incentive to recommend products based on the compensation rather than on a client's needs.
The SEC and NASAA add that a professional selling variable annuities may be regulated both as a registered representative of a broker-dealer and as an insurance agent. An individual's Form ADV Part 2B, Item 4 must disclose commissions, bonuses or other sales-based pay, so a reader can check a specific professional's disclosure.
Which is better, fee-based or fee-only?
The regulatory forms give no ranking: neither "fee-only" nor "fee-based" appears in the text of Form ADV Part 1A, Part 2 or the Form ADV instructions that The Paper Trail read, so neither has a regulatory definition there. A reader can compare how an adviser says it is paid in Form ADV Part 2A, Item 5 against the label the adviser uses. Investor.gov says a transaction-based fee may suit a person who trades rarely, while an asset-based fee may cost more but suit someone wanting ongoing advice.
Sources
- Fees and Commissions (FINRA)
- Investor Bulletin: Making Sense of Financial Professional Titles (SEC and NASAA)
- Regulation Best Interest, Form CRS and related interpretations (SEC)
- Form ADV Part 1A, Items 5.E and 6.A (SEC)
- Form ADV Part 2 instructions, Items 5.E and 10 and Part 2B Item 4 (SEC)
- Form CRS instructions, Item 3 (SEC)
- Investor Bulletin: Understanding Margin Accounts (SEC, published on Investor.gov)
- Investor Bulletin: Opening an Investment Advisory Account (SEC, published on Investor.gov)
- Investor Bulletin: How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio (SEC)
- Investor Bulletin: Top Tips for Selecting a Financial Professional (SEC)
- Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers (SEC)
- Frequently Asked Questions on Regulation Best Interest (SEC)