Each creates an incentive that may not match the client's interest.
Why must an investment adviser disclose conflicts of interest?
As a fiduciary, an adviser must eliminate conflicts of interest or disclose them fully and fairly so a client can give informed consent, the SEC said in its 2019 interpretation. The interpretation adds that disclosing that an adviser "may" have a conflict is not adequate when the conflict actually exists.
Disclosure is not the end of the obligation. An SEC staff bulletin on conflicts says disclosure of conflicts alone does not satisfy the obligation to act in a retail investor's best interest, and some conflicts may need to be mitigated or eliminated.
What are soft dollars?
"Soft dollar benefits" are research or other products or services, other than trade execution, that an adviser receives from a broker or a third party in connection with client trades. Item 12 of the Form ADV Part 2A brochure requires the adviser to explain that it benefits because it does not have to produce or pay for those services.
The Form ADV Part 2A brochure must also disclose that the adviser may have an incentive to choose a broker for the research rather than for the best execution of client trades, and whether clients may pay higher commissions as a result. It must describe the types of products and services acquired with client commissions in the last fiscal year, specifically enough for clients to understand them.
Form ADV Part 2A, Item 12 covers a related practice: choosing brokers because they send the adviser client referrals.
What are custodian benefits?
A custodian is the broker, bank or other firm that holds client assets. The SEC staff bulletin lists, among third-party arrangements firms should disclose, agreements to receive payments, loan forgiveness or expense offsets from a custodian for recommending that retail investors keep their assets there. It also lists payments from a clearing broker for recommending that clients invest in certain mutual fund share classes on its platform.
In the brochure, Item 14 requires an adviser to describe arrangements in which someone who is not a client provides an economic benefit for advising clients, including sales awards and other prizes, and to explain the conflicts and how it addresses them.
What is revenue sharing?
Revenue sharing is defined in the Form CRS instructions as investments where the manager or sponsor, or another third party, shares with the firm revenue it earns on those investments. It is one of four examples, along with proprietary products, other third-party payments and principal trading, that a firm's relationship summary must explain where they apply, including the incentives each creates.
The SEC conflicts bulletin also lists sub-accounting and administrative services fees paid by a fund or its adviser, and revenue sharing or other compensation tied to cash sweep programs.
What are 12b-1 fees?
12b-1 fees are paid out of a mutual fund's assets to cover distribution and sometimes shareholder services, the SEC explains. Distribution fees can compensate brokers and others who sell fund shares. The fees take their name from the SEC rule that lets a fund pay them only under an adopted plan.
FINRA Rule 2341 bars member firms from selling funds whose asset-based sales charges exceed 0.75% of average annual net assets, or whose service fees exceed 0.25%. Member firms may not describe a fund as "no load" if it has a front-end or deferred sales charge or if its sales-related charges and service fees together exceed 0.25% a year.
When an adviser or its people accept pay for selling investments, including asset-based sales charges or service fees from mutual funds, Item 5.E of the brochure requires disclosing it as a conflict and saying clients may buy the recommended products through other, unaffiliated brokers. The brochure supplement for an individual must disclose distribution or service ("trail") fees the person receives.
Where else do an adviser's conflicts appear?
An adviser's conflicts also appear in Item 10 of the Form ADV brochure, on affiliations and payments from other advisers the firm recommends; in Item 11, on recommending securities in which the firm has a financial interest and on personal trading; in Part 2B, Item 5, on economic benefits an individual receives from non-clients; and in the Form CRS section on how financial professionals make money.
- Item 10 of the brochure: affiliations with broker-dealers, fund companies, insurers and others, and payments from other advisers the firm recommends.
- Item 11: recommending securities in which the firm has a financial interest, and personal trading in the same securities.
- Part 2B, Item 5: economic benefits an individual receives from non-clients, including sales-based bonuses.
- Form CRS, "How do your financial professionals make money?": whether pay depends on assets serviced, products sold, or commissions.
For brokers, Regulation Best Interest requires firms to eliminate sales contests, sales quotas, bonuses and non-cash compensation tied to selling specific securities within a limited period, according to the SEC's compliance guide.
Where can you find an adviser's conflict disclosures?
An adviser's conflict disclosures are public: brochures and relationship summaries for registered advisers appear on the SEC's adviser database. A firm's Form CRS must point readers to more detailed conflict disclosures, such as its brochure, where Items 5, 10, 11, 12 and 14 of Form ADV Part 2A cover the arrangements described in this guide.
Sources
- Form ADV Part 2 instructions, Items 5, 10, 11, 12 and 14 and Part 2B (SEC)
- Form CRS instructions, Item 3 (SEC)
- Staff Bulletin: Standards of Conduct for Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers, Conflicts of Interest (SEC)
- Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers (SEC)
- Regulation Best Interest: A Small Entity Compliance Guide (SEC)
- Investor Bulletin: How Fees and Expenses Affect Your Investment Portfolio (SEC)
- FINRA Rule 2341, Investment Company Securities (FINRA)