---
title: "How We Rate Trust companies"
canonical: "https://papertrailfinance.com/trust-companies/methodology"
as_of: 2026-11-09
updated: 2026-11-09
type: methodology
publisher: "The Paper Trail"
firm_type: "trust-companies"
sources:
  - name: "its chartering regulator and the FDIC's BankFind Suite"
    url: "https://banks.data.fdic.gov/bankfind-suite/bankfind"
---

# How We Rate Trust companies

The Paper Trail profiles 105 trust companies and scores them on version 1.3 of a written rubric; none has a published score. This page is the rubric as the rating program applies it: each factor and its weight, the evidence it uses, when a factor is left out, and the gate a score must pass. Records last read Nov. 9, 2026.

This rubric is version 1.3. The program that applies it is shared with banks and credit unions and carries its own version number, 1.7; the rules are the ones written on this page.

The scoring program and the second program that recomputes every score on each rebuild were written by the same research team, so the second program checks the arithmetic, not the reading of the rules. The check of the written rules is a re-implementation by a different reviewer, who built the rubric from this page alone without opening either program. When run against version 1.3 of this rubric (version dated Nov. 10, 2026), the re-implementation scored the one factor that can be scored (8 firms) the same way for all 105 trust companies and left every firm unrated, as the rubric says, with no mismatches. Version 1.3, the one on this page, is the version that re-implementation checked.

## What weights does the rating program use?

These weights are read from the scored profiles themselves, so they match every score on the site; trust companies are profiled, not rated, so none carries a score. A factor without enough evidence for a firm is left out and the remaining weights are scaled up to 100%.

| Factor | Weight |
| --- | --- |
| Regulatory record | 40% |
| Fiduciary scale and condition | 30% |
| Financial strength | 30% |


## What is the short answer?
For trust companies that are not FDIC-insured banks, **the public record does not support an honest 0 to 10 rating today**. They file no public Call Report; the regulators publish a name, a charter type and sometimes a license number, not capital, assets, fiduciary assets or examination results. A rating built on a clean enforcement search alone would score "no known action" as quality, which the program's rule forbids (missing data is never good or bad). So the rubric below defines the factors we would score if the data existed, scores only what is real, and **gates every trust company at "profile, not rated" until a financial or fiduciary-condition factor can be scored from a public record.** All 105 profiled firms (v1.3) are profile-only: no overall score is given, no rating is published, the rating status is not rated, the reason given is that it is a profile and not rated.

## Which factors are scored, and how much does each weigh?
| Factor | Key | Weight | Inputs | Coverage today |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regulatory record | regulatory record | 40% | Formal actions against the trust company by its chartering regulator, resolved or in force | OCC national trust banks only (8 of 105 in-scope firms); state regulators' published orders are shown where readable, never scored |
| Fiduciary scale and condition | fiduciary scale | 30% | A published fiduciary-asset total and condition report (FDIC RC-T for insured trust banks; none exists for non-insured firms) | none for non-insured firms |
| Financial strength | financial strength | 30% | Published capital and earnings (Call Report) | none for non-insured firms |

- **Regulatory record, when searched** (OCC list, same method as banks): start at 10; each OCC formal action still in force -4; each action terminated or one-time order in the last 5 years -2; each civil money penalty of $250,000 or more in the last 5 years an extra -1; floor 0. Pending matters and allegations are shown, never scored. Individuals' orders never attach to the firm.
- **Not scored (N/A) and renormalized:** any factor whose input is absent. Weights are renormalized over the scored factors; the page names which factors were scored.
- **Overall** (only if the gate passes) = weighted mean of the scored factors x10, rounded once, half-up.

## How is the outside record scored?
Regulatory record (it rests on the regulator's list, not on anything the firm writes).

## How is confidence set?
Same points as banks: one per scored outside-record factor, +1 if both fiduciary scale and financial strength are scored, +1 if independently verified. High 4 or more, Medium 3, Low 2 or fewer. A trust company with only the OCC record and verification is Low.

## When is a score published?
A rating publishes only if ALL hold: (1) all three factors are scored (at least 3 of 3); (2) the regulatory record rests on a completed search of the chartering regulator's list; (3) confidence is Medium or High; (4) independently verified. Otherwise the firm gets a **profile without a rating**: regulator facts, the outside record (actions found, leads labeled unverified), and the sentence "No public financial or fiduciary-condition data exists for this type of firm, so it is not rated." Today condition (1) fails for every non-insured trust company, by design.

## When can a trust company be rated?
- It is an FDIC-insured bank or trust bank: it moves to the bank list and is rated under that rubric (Schedule RC-T supplies its fiduciary assets).
- The regulator publishes financial statements, examination ratings or fiduciary assets in a machine-readable form (named candidates: the FFIEC Call Report for OCC-chartered uninsured trust banks; Wyoming and Nevada exam-summary disclosures if they appear).

## What does the profile show instead?
Charter and regulator, license id (where published), city, as-of date of the regulator's list; whether the OCC lists any formal action (with the quote); parent group where the legal name says so; leads from news or regulator pages, each labeled unverified until read against the primary record.

## Which thresholds are used, and where do they come from?
- Regulatory definitions and anchors: none needed (no peer percentiles are computed: fewer than 8 trust companies have any scoreable input).
- Enforcement window: OCC monthly enforcement releases 2018 to Nov. 9, 2026.

## How complete are the fields on these profiles?

For each field, how many of the 105 trust company profiles carry a value; how many have the source read and the field blank or not reported there ("not disclosed in the source"); and how many have no such fact at all ("not collected").

**Field completeness, 105 trust company profiles**

| Field | Present | Not disclosed in the source | Not collected |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Name | 105 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| City | 70 (66.7%) | 35 (33.3%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| State | 105 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Regulator | 105 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Charter category | 105 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| License or charter id | 29 (27.6%) | 76 (72.4%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Enforcement search | 105 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |

Why license or charter id is missing: not published by the regulator: its list row (quoted) gives no licence or charter number (76).

## What changed in each version?

- **Data note, Nov. 11, 2026: trust rubric stays v1.3.**
- **Version 1.3, Nov. 10, 2026: no rating rule change; scope and coverage.** What changed: scope is written down; enforcement.
- **Version 1.2, Nov. 10, 2026: no rule change; record fixes.**
- **Version 1.0, Nov. 9, 2026.** First rubric.

This page is the written rubric the rating program follows, with file names and internal codes put in words. Individuals are never rated, pending matters and allegations are shown but never scored, and missing data is never counted as good or bad. Information, not investment advice.
