The Paper Trail
The Paper TrailFind a Firm
Helmstar Wealth Management logo

Helmstar Wealth Management

Registered investment adviser · Boise, Idaho · CRD 145074 · SEC 801-108320 · Legal name: The Helmstar Group

View SEC filing

Helmstar Wealth Management is an SEC-registered investment adviser in Boise, Idaho, managing $786 million for 523 individual clients. Its fee on $1 million is about $10,000 a year (1.00%). The Paper Trail rates it 93 out of 100, medium confidence. Regulator records searched Nov. 9, 2026 show no resolved regulatory action against the firm as an investment adviser. SEC data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026.

Assets managed
$786M
Individual clients
523
Employees
12
Offices
1
Fee on $1M
$10,000
The Paper Trail rating
93/100

SEC data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026; latest Form ADV filing 03/27/2026. Page last updated . Information, not investment advice.

Fee schedule

Portfolio Management Services

Published rate by account sizeEffective rate (fee ÷ account)0%0.25%0.50%0.75%1.00%1.25%$25K$100K$250K$500K$1M$2M$5M$10M$20MFEE A YEAREFFECTIVE RATE$2,5001.00%$5,0001.00%$10,0001.00%$18,5000.92%
$10,000 a year on $1 million (1.00%), each rate on its own band. Source: firm's Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7 (Item 5).

Conflicts of interest

5 of 15 kinds disclosed

Disclosed 5Unclear 0Not disclosed 10Benefits from custodiansInsurance salesOutside businessCommissionsRollover recommendationsSoft dollarsPays for client referralsOwn or affiliated products12b-1 / trail feesPaid for referralsRevenue sharingPrivate fundsPerformance-based feesAffiliated broker-dealerPrincipal or cross trades
Disclosed 5, unclear 0, not disclosed 10 of the 15 kinds we track. Source: firm's Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Form ADV Part 1A.

The Paper Trail Rating

93/100

Confidence: Medium · 7 of 8 factors scored · How we rate advisers

The Paper Trail rates Helmstar Wealth Management 93 out of 100, scored on 7 of the 8 factors.

Among rated advisers: not ranked among hand-decoded advisers because only 80% of the rubric's weight could be scored (ranking needs 85%).

Helmstar Wealth Management's rating, like every hand-decoded rating, shows confidence no higher than Medium: blind re-reads of published ratings found about 3 in 100 filing facts wrong after adjudication, and an overall score is typically within about ±3 points of the corrected value.

The margin of about ±3 points on Helmstar Wealth Management's rating covers errors in reading the filings, measured in the blind checks; it does not cover missing data. For Helmstar Wealth Management, 1 of the 8 factors could not be scored; scoring it at the median of the published firms instead of leaving it out would not change its overall score.

Score by factor
FactorWeightScore (0–10)
Client reviews20%N/A
Regulatory record15%10.0
Complaint record10%10.0
Cost15%10.0
Fee transparency10%10.0
Conflicts of interest15%7.8
Disclosure consistency10%10.0
Fiduciary standing5%6.0
  • Client reviews: not scored, only 4 public reviews; at least 10 are needed. Its weight is shared among the scored factors.
  • Conflicts of interest −1.5: Advisers sell insurance, and their pay depends partly on insurance products sold.
  • Conflicts of interest −0.5: The firm pays SmartAsset, a lead-generation service, for client referrals.
  • Conflicts of interest −0.25: The firm earns more when clients roll employer plan money into IRAs it manages, and the plan may cost less.
  • Fiduciary standing −4: Fiduciary only when giving investment advice (its people also sell commissioned products).

Regulatory and Complaint Record

Helmstar Wealth Management has no resolved regulatory action against the firm on record, according to a search of the SEC's adviser records, FINRA and the Idaho Department of Finance, Securities Bureau completed on Nov. 9, 2026 and re-checked by a second researcher.

No Better Business Bureau listing for Helmstar Wealth Management was found.

Searched Nov. 9, 2026 under 2 names: SEC IAPD firm record; SEC IAPD: Form ADV Part 1 (Item 11 and disclosure pages); FINRA BrokerCheck; Idaho Department of Finance site search; Idaho Department of Finance Admin Actions: Securities > Enforcement Orders (all 20 list pages). Not available to our search and not counted: SEC enforcement search: litigation releases (HTTP 403), SEC enforcement search: administrative proceedings (HTTP 403). Re-checked by a second researcher Nov. 9, 2026.

Quick Answers

Is Helmstar Wealth Management registered, and who regulates it?

Helmstar Wealth Management is registered with the SEC as an investment adviser (CRD 145074, SEC file 801-108320), and the SEC regulates it. Its registration status in the SEC's record is "Approved". The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure record for the firm lists its Form ADV, brochures and Form CRS.

Source: SEC investment adviser data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026

Is Helmstar Wealth Management a fiduciary?

Helmstar Wealth Management acts in clients' best interest as an investment adviser; its advisers also sell insurance on commission.

Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure / Form CRS

Who is Helmstar Wealth Management for?

On average it manages about $398,000 per account and $1.5 million per individual client (averages, not minimums). Its account minimum is $500,000, which it may waive. Individuals and high-net-worth individuals account for 97% of its assets.

Source: Form ADV Part 1A Items 5.D and 5.F (filed March 27, 2026); Form ADV Part 2A brochure

How much does Helmstar Wealth Management charge?

On a $1 million account, Helmstar Wealth Management's main published fee schedule ("Portfolio Management Services") works out to about $10,000 a year (1%) before fund and trading costs. The firm says fees are negotiable.

Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Item 5

Does Helmstar Wealth Management earn money other than advisory fees?

Its filings disclose commissions on securities or insurance, insurance sales by the firm or its people and paying others for client referrals, which can give the firm or its people a financial interest in what they recommend. Each is quoted from the filing in the conflicts section.

Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Form CRS and Form ADV, as read and verified by The Paper Trail

Who owns Helmstar Wealth Management?

Helmstar Wealth Management is privately held and primarily owned by its two managing members; no indirect owners are reported.

Source: Form ADV Schedule A

Has Helmstar Wealth Management been disciplined by regulators?

Helmstar Wealth Management reports no disciplinary events in Item 11 of its Form ADV, which covers the firm and its advisory affiliates.

Source: Form ADV, latest filing 03/27/2026, Item 11

Does Helmstar Wealth Management have an account minimum?

Helmstar Wealth Management suggests $500,000 to open and keep an account, which it may waive; there is no minimum fee.

Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Item 7

How big is Helmstar Wealth Management?

It manages $786 million in regulatory assets and serves about 523 individual clients, with 12 employees and 1 office.

Source: Form ADV, latest filing 03/27/2026, Items 5A, 5D and 5F

How many advisers does Helmstar Wealth Management have?

IAPD lists 7 investment adviser representatives at Helmstar Wealth Management (as of Oct. 14, 2026). Their median time in the industry is 19 years, and 71% have 10 or more years. 86% hold a Series 65 or 66 license.

Source: SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure, adviser records (firm totals only)

How have Helmstar Wealth Management's assets changed over ten years?

Its regulatory assets under management went from $110 million in Oct 2016 to $786 million in Oct 2026, a compound change of +21.7% a year over ten years.

Source: SEC monthly registered-adviser files, one per year, Form ADV Item 5F(2)(c)

Who holds my money at Helmstar Wealth Management?

Client accounts are held at SEI INVESTMENTS DISTRIBUTION CO. The firm reports in Form ADV Item 9 that it does not have custody of client assets; its brochure says a third-party custodian holds them.

Source: Form ADV Item 9 and Schedule D 5.K(3) (filed March 27, 2026); brochure Item 15

How is Helmstar Wealth Management rated on Google?

Helmstar Wealth Management has 4 Google reviews across 1 listing, averaging 5 out of 5 (retrieved Oct. 14, 2026). That is fewer than 10 reviews, too few to judge the firm by.

Source: Google's public review count and rating for the business listings on the firm's Form ADV website

Who It's For

Average account
$398K per account on average ($786M across 1,974 accounts). About $1.5M per individual client. These are averages, not minimums.
Account minimum
$500,000. The suggested $500,000 minimum may be waived at the firm's discretion, and smaller accounts may be accepted. Form CRS, p. 1: The minimum account size for opening and maintaining an account with our firm is $500,000, which may be waived at our discretion.
Client mix
Clients and assets by client type, Form ADV Item 5.D
Client typeClientsAssetsShare
High-net-worth individuals227$662M84.2%
Individuals296$99M12.6%
Pension and profit-sharing plans12$15M1.9%
Charitable organizations2$10M1.2%
State or local governments1$483,1200.1%
Individuals and high-net-worth individuals account for 96.8% of the assets the firm manages.
Services
  • Financial planning
  • Estate planning
  • Retirement planning
  • Hourly or project planning
  • Outside managers
  • Alternatives and private funds
  • Retirement plan consulting
  • Pension consulting
Stand-alone planning
Offered. The firm offers financial planning separately from portfolio management for a fixed fee of generally $750 to $15,000, or in some cases an hourly fee of $100 to $300. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 4: Should you choose to act on any of our recommendations, you are not obligated to implement the financial plan through any of our other investment advisory services.
Investment approach
Allocates client assets among mutual funds, ETFs and outside sub-advisers' separately managed accounts, rather than analyzing individual securities, with attention to asset allocation and tax management. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 9: This philosophy is based upon five principles: asset allocation, portfolio structure, tax management, multiple specialist managers, and continuous portfolio management.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: Form ADV Part 1A Items 5.D and 5.F (filed March 27, 2026); Form ADV Part 2A brochure (dated March 26, 2026); Form CRS (dated Oct. 29, 2024).

What You'd Pay

Helmstar Wealth Management's main schedule: Portfolio Management Services, billed quarterly in arrears, on the balance at the end of the billing period. The firm says fees are negotiable.

Helmstar Wealth Management's published fee schedule (each rate applies to its band)
AssetsAnnual rate
First $1,000,0001.00%
$1,000,000 to $2,000,0000.85%
$2,000,000 to $3,000,0000.70%
$3,000,000 to $5,000,0000.60%
$5,000,000 to $10,000,0000.45%
$10,000,000 to $15,000,0000.30%
$15,000,000 to $20,000,0000.20%
$20,000,000 to $100,000,0000.15%
What Helmstar Wealth Management's advisory fee comes to
Account sizePer yearEffective rateOver 20 years*
$250,000$2,5001.00%$138,460
$500,000$5,0001.00%$275,730
$1,000,000$10,0001.00%$524,856
$2,000,000$18,5000.93%$935,188

Advisory fee only, from Helmstar Wealth Management's published schedule; fund expenses, custody and trading costs are extra. *Over 20 years = how much less the account would hold after paying the fee each year, assuming a 6% annual return before fees and no withdrawals. Illustration, not a forecast.

  • The outside asset-management programs the firm uses charge their own program fee for advisory, custody or trading services, on top of Helmstar's fee. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 6: Specific fees charged by the sub-adviser will be disclosed in their disclosure documents provided to you at the time the account[s] is opened.
  • Mutual funds and ETFs charge their own management fees and expenses. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: The fees that you pay to our firm for investment advisory services are separate and distinct from the fees and expenses charged by mutual funds or exchange traded funds
  • The custodian or broker may charge transaction and brokerage fees; the firm does not share in them. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: We do not share in any portion of the brokerage fees/transaction charges imposed by the broker-dealer or custodian.
  • Money placed in outside private funds counts toward the firm's fee, and the firm's fee is charged in addition to the fund's own fees. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 5: the amount of assets invested in the fund[s] shall be included as part of "assets under management" for purposes of Advisor calculating its investment advisory fee. Advisor's fee shall be in addition to the fund's fees.
Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: Annual Fee Schedule Annual Fee Average Annual Fee Range

How Else the Firm Makes Money

Helmstar Wealth Management's filings were read for 16 kinds of conflict of interest: 6 present and 10 not present.

  • Yes

    Commissions

    The firm's advisers are independent insurance agents who earn commissions on insurance they sell to clients, in addition to advisory fees. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: Persons providing investment advice on behalf of our firm are licensed as independent insurance agents. These persons will earn commission-based compensation for selling insurance products, including insurance products they sell to you.
  • Yes

    Insurance sales

    Advisers sell insurance, and their pay depends partly on insurance products sold. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: Insurance commissions earned by these persons are separate and in addition to our advisory fees.
  • Yes

    Pays for client referrals

    The firm pays SmartAsset, a lead-generation service, for client referrals. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 13: We compensate Smart Asset as a lead generator for advisory referrals.
  • Yes

    Benefits from custodians

    Schwab and SEI give the firm research, technology and other benefits at no charge, which gives it a reason to recommend them. Form CRS, p. 2: We do receive third-party research, technology services, and other benefits at no charge to us from Charles Schwab & Co, Inc. and SEI Private Trust Co. This gives us an incentive to recommend that you use this custodian which represents a conflict of interest.
  • Yes

    Rollover recommendations

    The firm earns more when clients roll employer plan money into IRAs it manages, and the plan may cost less. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 6: We benefit financially from the rollover of your assets from a retirement account to an account that we manage or provide investment advice, because the assets increase our assets under management and, in turn, our advisory fees.
  • Yes

    Other

    The firm does not combine client orders, so clients may pay different prices and costs for the same trades. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12: We do not combine multiple orders for shares of the same securities purchased for advisory accounts we manage
  • No

    12b-1 / trail fees

    The firm says it receives no compensation from third parties for its investment advice. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 13: We do not receive any compensation from any third party in connection with providing investment advice to you.
  • No

    Revenue sharing

    The firm says it does not use revenue sharing. Form CRS, p. 2: We do not utilize any proprietary products, principal trading, or revenue sharing.
  • No

    Own or affiliated products

    The firm says it does not use proprietary products. Form CRS, p. 2: We do not utilize any proprietary products, principal trading, or revenue sharing.
  • No

    Affiliated broker-dealer

    The firm reports no material relationship with a broker-dealer. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 11: We have not provided information on other financial industry activities and affiliations because we do not have any relationship or arrangement that is material to our advisory business or to our clients with any of the types of entities listed below.
  • No

    Paid for referrals

    The firm says it receives no compensation from sub-advisers it recommends or from other third parties. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 11: We will not receive separate compensation, directly or indirectly, from the sub- adviser for recommending that you use their services.
  • No

    Soft dollars

    The firm says it has no soft-dollar arrangements; custodian research it receives is described separately. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12: We do not have any soft dollar arrangements.
  • No

    Principal or cross trades

    The firm says it does not engage in principal trading. Form CRS, p. 2: We do not utilize any proprietary products, principal trading, or revenue sharing.
  • No

    Performance-based fees

    The firm does not charge performance-based fees. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 8: We do not accept performance-based fees or participate in side-by-side management.
  • No

    Private funds

    The firm manages no private funds; it may recommend outside private funds to qualified clients and include them in its fee base. Form ADV Part 1, p. 14: SECTION 7.B.(1) Private Fund Reporting No Information Filed
  • No

    Outside business

    Apart from advisers' insurance sales, the firm reports no material outside business relationships. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 11: we do not have any relationship or arrangement that is material to our advisory business or to our clients with any of the types of entities listed below.

How Client Money Is Held

The firm reports in Form ADV Item 9 that it does not have custody of client assets; its brochure says a third-party custodian holds them.

Custodians
  • SEI INVESTMENTS DISTRIBUTION CO. (Oaks, PA), holding $752M of the firm's separately managed account assets.
Qualified custodians in all (Item 9.F): 3.
Affiliates
Form ADV Item 7.A reports no related persons.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: Form ADV Part 1A Items 7 and 9 and Schedule D 5.K(3), 7.A, 7.B(1) and 9.C, filed March 27, 2026; what gives the firm custody, from its brochure (Item 15). Names as filed.

Ownership and Fiduciary Status

Ownership, as filed

Helmstar Wealth ManagementThomas Frank SteelmanManaging MemberCode D · 50% to under 75%Benjamin Hans BoettcherManaging MemberCode D · 50% to under 75%0%50%100%
2 owners listed (2 people, 0 entities); bars show the range each Form ADV code stands for. No outside owner is reported. Source: firm's Form ADV Part 1A, Schedules A and B.
Who owns it
Helmstar Wealth Management is privately held and primarily owned by its two managing members; no indirect owners are reported. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 4: We are primarily owned by Benjamin Boettcher and Thomas Steelman.
Fiduciary status
Helmstar Wealth Management acts in clients' best interest as an investment adviser; its advisers also sell insurance on commission. Form CRS, p. 2: When we act as your investment adviser, we must act in your best interest and not put our interest ahead of yours.
Disciplinary history
The firm reports no legal or disciplinary events. Form ADV Part 2A, p. 11: We do not have any required disclosures under this item.

Team

Advisers
7
Median years in industry
19
10 or more years
71%
Series 65 or 66
86%
Series 7
57%
Also with a broker-dealer
0%

Credentials held, among the 7 advisers with a brochure supplement: CFP 57%, CFA 14%, ChFC 14%; 71% hold at least one.

Disclosure figures are shown for firms with 10 or more advisers.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure records of the firm’s current investment adviser representatives, retrieved Oct. 14, 2026; firm totals only, no individual is shown. Experience counts years since the industry start date IAPD calculates. Credentials from the Form ADV Part 2B brochure supplements. Form ADV Item 5.B(1) reports 8 employees in advisory roles.

Ten-Year Record

SEC filings, 2016–2026

Assets under management and individual clients, by year

ASSETS UNDER MANAGEMENT0$500M$1B$110M$786MINDIVIDUAL CLIENTS05001,000——3375232016201720182019202020212022202320242025*2026
Assets under management went from $110M (Oct 2016) to $786M (Oct 2026), a compound change of +21.7% a year over ten years (+24.8% over five). Individual clients: 337 (Oct 2018) to 523 (Oct 2026). "—" under clients: that year's file has no client count. *Sep 2025: the SEC published no October 2025 file, so the Sep 2025 file is used. Source: SEC monthly registered-adviser files, one per year, Form ADV Items 5F(2)(c) and 5D(a)(1) + 5D(b)(1).

Name changes and moves

  • Oct 2023 to Oct 2024Business name changed from THE HELMSTAR GROUP, LLC to HELMSTAR WEALTH MANAGEMENT.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: SEC monthly registered-adviser files (sec.gov), one per year: October 2016–2026, except Sep 2025 (no October file that year). The latest point is the firm’s current Form ADV. A change is dated to the two files it falls between.

Client Reviews

4 Google reviews across 1 Google listing, rated 5 out of 5. That is fewer than 10 reviews, too few to judge the firm by.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: Google’s public review count and rating for the business listings on the firm’s Form ADV website, retrieved Oct. 14, 2026. Which listings count: how we rate advisers.

Where the Firm's Documents Disagree

Read side by side, the firm’s brochure, Form CRS and Form ADV do not contradict each other.

Source for Helmstar Wealth Management: Form ADV Part 2A brochure (dated March 26, 2026); Form CRS (dated Oct. 29, 2024); Form ADV Part 1A (filed March 27, 2026), compared by The Paper Trail.

Compare With Other Idaho Advisers

Comparison of Helmstar Wealth Management with other advisers in the same state
FirmCityAssetsIndividual clientsFee on $1M
Helmstar Wealth ManagementBoise$786M523$10,000
American Independent Securities GroupEagle$986M4,339Up to $25,000
Continuum AdvisoryEagle$1.9B3,344Up to $29,500
Legacy Wealth ManagementBoise$629M3,269Up to $20,000
Pinkerton Wealth PartnersCoeur D'Alene$1.4B1,233Up to $20,000
Sand Creek CapitalRexburg$471M939Up to $20,000
HRC Wealth ManagementMoscow$487M878Up to $10,000

Filings Behind This Page

  • SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure: Helmstar Wealth Management (registration, Form ADV, brochures, Form CRS)
  • Form ADV Part 2A Brochure (with Part 2B supplements) (dated March 26, 2026)
  • ADV Part 3: Form CRS Relationship Summary (dated Oct. 29, 2024)
  • Form ADV Part 1A (Other-Than-Annual Amendment) (dated March 27, 2026)
  • SEC, Information About Registered Investment Advisers: the SEC's monthly adviser file dated Nov. 2, 2026 (last read Nov. 11, 2026)

The day each source was read for Helmstar Wealth Management:

  • SEC monthly adviser file, read Nov. 11, 2026
  • Form ADV Part 2A brochures and Form CRS, read Oct. 14, 2026
  • SEC, FINRA and state regulator records and court searches, read Nov. 9, 2026
  • Google reviews, read Oct. 14, 2026