Bank
Buffalo Federal Bank
Bank · Buffalo, Wyoming · FDIC certificate 29696 · RSSD 108072
Buffalo Federal Bank is a bank headquartered in Buffalo, Wyoming. It reports total assets of $203 million, a Tier 1 leverage ratio of 10.38%, and a Satisfactory CRA rating. The Paper Trail scores it 77 out of 100 with high confidence, strongest on enforcement record and weakest on earnings. Figures are as of . Information, not investment advice.
Buffalo Federal Bank was formerly known as Buffalo Federal Savings and Loan Association and Buffalo Federal Savings Bank. This profile covers Buffalo Federal Bank, one legal entity of the group owned by the holding company Crazy Woman Creek Bcorp Inc (FDIC records, as of June 30, 2026); it does not rate Crazy Woman Creek Bcorp Inc or the group as a whole.
- Total assets
- $203 million
- Tier 1 leverage ratio
- 10.38%
- Return on assets
- 1.31%
- CRA rating
- Satisfactory (S)
- Enforcement search
- Searched: 0 in force
- The Paper Trail rating
- 77/100
- Among rated banks
- Higher than 65%
Data as of , last read ; 2 sources (Federal Reserve enforcement data file and CRA ratings; FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders) re-checked with no change. Each fact below carries its own source and as-of date. Information, not investment advice.
How does The Paper Trail rate Buffalo Federal Bank?
Buffalo Federal Bank scores 77 out of 100 as a bank, with high confidence, as of : higher than 65% of the 394 rated banks that are ranked. 6 of 6 factors had enough evidence to score. The highest factor is enforcement record (10.0 of 10) and the lowest is earnings (5.0 of 10).
Buffalo Federal Bank's score combines capital strength (28%), asset quality (22%), earnings (11%), funding and liquidity (11%), enforcement record (16%) and CRA rating (12%); consumer complaints are shown but not scored. It is not a guarantee of safety or a statement about deposit insurance, and a check that was not run is left out, never counted as clean.
Buffalo Federal Bank was scored on 100% of the rubric's weight. Every factor in the rubric was scored.
| Factor | Weight | Score (0-10) | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital strength | 28% | 7.1 | Tier 1 leverage ratio of 10.38%, above the 5% well-capitalized line; the top tenth of Western banks hold 17.9% or more. This bank uses the community bank leverage framework, so only the leverage ratio is tested. |
| Asset quality | 22% | 7.9 | Asset quality: noncurrent loans are 0.67% of loans (the weakest tenth of Western banks have 2.47% or more), nonperforming assets are 0.50% of assets, net charge-offs are -0.004% of loans. |
| Earnings | 11% | 5.0 | Earnings: return on assets is 1.31% (the best tenth of Western banks earn 2.41% or more) and the efficiency ratio is 64.8% (lower is better). |
| Funding and liquidity | 11% | 9.0 | Funding: brokered deposits are 0.0% of deposits and estimated uninsured deposits are 18.9% of deposits (the highest tenth of Western banks have 50.8% or more). |
| Enforcement record | 16% | 10.0 | The published enforcement records of the Federal Reserve and FDIC show 0 formal actions still in force and 0 terminated actions or one-time orders in the last five years. |
| CRA rating | 12% | 7.0 | Its latest published Community Reinvestment Act rating is Satisfactory (). |
Notes on how each factor was computed
- Capital strength: the measure that sets the score is the tier 1 leverage ratio of 10.38% (well-capitalized 5.0%, the West's 90th percentile is 17.87%); CBLR elector, leverage only
- Asset quality: noncurrent loans 50%, nonperforming assets 25%, net charge-offs 25%, each scaled 0 at the 90th percentile to 10 at the 10th percentile of West banks
- Earnings: return on assets 60% (10th to 90th percentile, higher is better), efficiency ratio 40% (90th to 10th percentile, lower is better)
- Funding and liquidity: brokered deposits and estimated uninsured deposits as % of deposits, each 0 at the 90th percentile to 10 at the 10th percentile of West banks
- Enforcement record: Federal Reserve and FDIC formal actions against the bank: 0 in force, 0 terminated or one-time in 5 years, 0 penalties at least $250,000
- CRA rating: latest published CRA overall rating Satisfactory ()
Buffalo Federal Bank's score runs 0 to 100 and is computed from the factors above (a weighted mean of the scored factors, with N/A factors excluded). Missing data is never counted as good or bad; pending matters are shown but never scored; individuals are never rated.
Source: The Paper Trail's scoring under the written rubric for banks (/banks/methodology), from the sourced facts on this page; as of .
What do public records say about Buffalo Federal Bank?
Buffalo Federal Bank's public records show total assets of $203 million, tier 1 leverage ratio of 10.38% and return on assets of 1.31%. They are among 36 sourced facts listed here as of . Each row gives its source, the exact quote or value read, and the date the source value is as of.
| Fact | Value | Source | As of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total assets | $203 million | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: total assets ($ thousands): 202578; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Total deposits | $176 million | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: total deposits ($ thousands): 175859; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Total equity capital | $18.3 million | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: equity capital ($ thousands): 18342; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Offices | 3 offices | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: offices: 3; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Primary federal regulator | FED | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: primary federal regulator: the Federal Reserve; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| FDIC bank class | Commercial bank, state charter, Federal Reserve member, Federal Reserve-supervised | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: SM; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Holding company | CRAZY WOMAN CREEK BCORP INC | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: holding company: CRAZY WOMAN CREEK BCORP INC; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Established | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: date established: 05/01/1936; read from the FDIC's data service | ||
| Tier 1 leverage ratio | 10.38% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: Tier 1 leverage ratio: 10.38%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Common equity tier 1 ratio | Not reported (community bank leverage ratio election) | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: common equity Tier 1 ratio: 0%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Tier 1 risk-based capital ratio | Not reported (community bank leverage ratio election) | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: Tier 1 risk-based capital ratio: 0%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Total risk-based capital ratio | Not reported (community bank leverage ratio election) | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: total risk-based capital ratio: 0%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Elected community bank leverage ratio framework | Yes | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: elected the community bank leverage ratio framework: yes; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Noncurrent loans to loans | 0.67% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: noncurrent loans, as a share of loans: 0.67%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Nonperforming assets to assets | 0.5% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: noncurrent assets plus other real estate owned, as a share of assets: 0.50%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Net charge-offs to loans | 0% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: net charge-offs, as a share of loans: -0.00%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Return on assets | 1.31% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: return on assets: 1.31%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Net interest margin | 4.43% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: net interest margin: 4.43%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Efficiency ratio | 64.83% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: efficiency ratio: 64.83%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Brokered deposits to deposits | 0% | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: brokered deposits ratio: 0%; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Estimated uninsured deposits to deposits (derived) | 18.94% | banks.data.fdic.govComputed from these filed values: estimated uninsured deposits ($ thousands): 33309; total deposits ($ thousands): 175859; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| CRA overall rating (latest in the Federal Reserve CRA listing) | Satisfactory (S) | federalreserve.govValue as filed: BUFFALO FEDERAL BANK - 108072; BUFFALO, WY; Satisfactory; exam Feb 24, 2025; public ; Small Bank | |
| Date the Federal Reserve made the rating public | federalreserve.govValue as filed: made public | ||
| Enforcement-list search | Searched | federalreserve.gov“Federal Reserve enforcement actions data file (1563 institution-level rows) searched for the name "Buffalo Federal Bank" in Buffalo: 0 rows; FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders searched by FDIC certificate 29696: 0 order records name the bank” | |
| Formal actions against the bank with no termination found | 0 actions | orders.fdic.govSearch result: 0 matching records | |
| Actions terminated or one-time orders in the last 5 years | 0 actions | orders.fdic.govSearch result: 0 matching records | |
| Civil money penalties of $250,000 or more in the last 5 years | 0 penalties | orders.fdic.govSearch result: 0 matching records | |
| CFPB complaint database search (not scored) | No CFPB company match (not a complaint-free finding) | consumerfinance.gov“No company name in the CFPB database equals 'Buffalo Federal Bank'. The CFPB publishes complaints it sends to companies for a response; it supervises banks and credit unions with more than $10 billion in assets, and complaints about smaller institutions are generally referred to their own regulator and do not appear in the database. An empty search is therefore not evidence of zero complaints”; read from the CFPB complaint database | |
| FDIC trust powers | Trust powers not known (FDIC code 00) | banks.data.fdic.govread from the FDIC's data service | |
| Fiduciary and related assets (Call Report fiduciary schedule) | $0 | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: fiduciary and related assets: 0; read from the FDIC's data service |
All other sourced facts (6)
The other 6 sourced facts about Buffalo Federal Bank as a bank, as of , each with its source and date.
| Fact | Value | Source | As of |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headquarters state | WY | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: headquarters state: WY; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Federal Reserve RSSD id | 108072 | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: Federal Reserve RSSD id: 108072; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Estimated uninsured deposits | $33.3 million | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: estimated uninsured deposits ($ thousands): 33309; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Fiduciary accounts (Call Report fiduciary schedule) | 0 accounts | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: fiduciary accounts: 0; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| Fiduciary income year to date (Call Report fiduciary schedule) | $0 | banks.data.fdic.govValue as filed: fiduciary income, year to date ($ thousands): 0; read from the FDIC's data service | |
| CRA examination date (Federal Reserve listing) | federalreserve.govValue as filed: examination date Feb 24, 2025 |
How has Buffalo Federal Bank changed over recent quarters?
Buffalo Federal Bank's total assets rose from $184 million on to $203 million on . Buffalo Federal Bank's figures are from the FDIC's quarterly call report data, to , as reported.
| Quarter ending | Total assets | Tier 1 leverage ratio | Total risk-based capital ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| $184 million | 9.37% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $191 million | 9.33% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $186 million | 9.56% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $184 million | 9.86% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $188 million | 10.15% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $193 million | 9.65% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $201 million | 9.68% | 10.82% | |
| $196 million | 9.88% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $195 million | 10.02% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $208 million | 9.96% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $210 million | 9.93% | Not reported (CBLR election) | |
| $203 million | 10.38% | Not reported (CBLR election) |
Buffalo Federal Bank elected the community bank leverage ratio framework, so it does not report risk-based capital ratios; the call report shows them as zero, which is not a real value.
How does Buffalo Federal Bank compare on its main figures?
Buffalo Federal Bank ranks 316th of 397 banks in the West on total assets ($203 million). Where Buffalo Federal Bank's main figures sit among every active bank with a profile here: the percentile is the share of firms with a lower figure (50th is the middle). A percentile is a position, not a grade. For nonperforming assets, lower is better.
| Figure | Value | Percentile among West firms | Among similar size | In the state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total assets | $203 million | 20th (n = 397) | 82nd (n = 99) | 25th (n = 24) |
| Tier 1 leverage ratio | 10.38% | 30th (n = 396) | 23rd (n = 99) | 38th (n = 24) |
| Return on assets | 1.31% | 58th (n = 397) | 67th (n = 99) | 50th (n = 24) |
| Nonperforming assets to assets | 0.5% | 61st (n = 397) | 63rd (n = 99) | 83rd (n = 24) |
Method: computed from the profiles on this site as of . Similar size means the same quarter of the total assets range among banks in the West.
Is Buffalo Federal Bank registered, and who regulates it?
Registration or charter of Buffalo Federal Bank: Commercial bank, state charter, Federal Reserve member, Federal Reserve-supervised. Supervision: FDIC-insured bank; primary federal regulator is Federal Reserve. Status in the regulator's record: active, FDIC-insured, since (the bank's establishment date). FDIC certificate number: 29696. No final regulatory action against the firm itself is on record in the sources read. Pending matters are listed separately and not counted. Record as of . Where to verify it: FDIC BankFind record.
Does Buffalo Federal Bank have a regulatory or legal record?
No regulatory, enforcement or legal matter is listed for Buffalo Federal Bank in the sources checked, as of . The record listed below for Buffalo Federal Bank (a CRA rating) is not a regulatory, enforcement or legal matter. That is a statement about what was found in those sources, not a guarantee; the sources are listed in the facts table.
Other records checked (1)
1 other record was checked for Buffalo Federal Bank; it is listed with its date and source and is not counted as a matter of the firm.
| Date | Record | What it shows | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRA performance rating | Community Reinvestment Act overall rating: Satisfactory; evaluation dated ; made public | federalreserve.gov |
How can I check Buffalo Federal Bank myself?
To check Buffalo Federal Bank yourself, use the FDIC's BankFind Suite. Search the bank's name or FDIC certificate number to see its charter, regulator, branches and quarterly financial reports. Search with the identifier shown at the top of this page: FDIC certificate 29696 · RSSD 108072.
How does Buffalo Federal Bank compare with other banks in Wyoming?
Buffalo Federal Bank ranks 18 of 24 banks headquartered in Wyoming in this dataset by total assets ($203 million); size is available for 24 of them.
| # | Firm | City | Total assets | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | Tanager Bank | Jackson | $222 million | 68 |
| 17 | Bank of Commerce | Rawlins | $216 million | 81 |
| 18 | Buffalo Federal Bank | Buffalo | $203 million | 77 |
| 19 | Central Bank and Trust | Lander | $203 million | 81 |
| 20 | State Bank | Green River | $115 million | 71 |
How is the score calculated?
Buffalo Federal Bank is assessed under the written rubric for its firm type. A factor is scored 0 to 10 from sourced facts, each factor has a published weight, factors without enough evidence are excluded and the rest are re-weighted, and a score is published only when the rubric's publication gate is met and the record's facts have been checked a second time (how Buffalo Federal Bank's facts were checked is under "Where does this information come from?").
Where does this information come from?
The 36 fact rows about Buffalo Federal Bank in the tables above come from 4 public sources. The source values are dated to . The day each source was read for this firm is listed below. Nothing here comes from the firm's marketing unless a fact says so, and each fact's source and exact quote are in its row. Second check: 25 underlying values behind these fact rows were recomputed from the source data by a second, separately written program on , and they matched; a sample was also re-read without the first reading in view.
- banks.data.fdic.gov: 28 facts
- federalreserve.gov: 4 facts
- orders.fdic.gov: 3 facts
- consumerfinance.gov: 1 fact
- FDIC BankFind (institutions and Call Reports), read ; re-checked with no change (32 facts)
- Federal Reserve enforcement data file and CRA ratings, read ; re-checked with no change (4 facts)
- FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders, read ; re-checked with no change (3 facts)
- CFPB complaints and enforcement, read (1 fact)