---
title: "American Independent Securities Group Review: Fees, Conflicts and Ownership"
canonical: "https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/american-independent-securities-group-135288"
as_of: 2026-11-02
updated: 2026-11-11
type: firm-profile
publisher: "The Paper Trail"
last_read: "2026-11-11"
firm_type: "advisers"
crd: "135288"
sec_file_number: "801-69138"
city: "Eagle"
state: "ID"
rating: 56
sources:
  - name: "SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure record for American Independent Securities Group"
    url: "https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288"
  - name: "SEC, Information About Registered Investment Advisers (monthly adviser data)"
    url: "https://www.sec.gov/data-research/sec-markets-data/information-about-registered-investment-advisers-exempt-reporting-advisers"
---

# American Independent Securities Group

American Independent Securities Group is an SEC-registered investment adviser in Eagle, Idaho, managing $986 million for 4,339 individual clients. Its fee on $1 million is up to $25,000 a year (2.50%). The Paper Trail rates it 56 out of 100, medium confidence. Its Form ADV reports 2 disciplinary disclosures for the firm or its affiliates (Item 11). SEC data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026.

American Independent Securities Group: registered investment adviser, Eagle, ID. CRD 135288, SEC file 801-69138. Source page: https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/american-independent-securities-group-135288
Data: the SEC's monthly adviser file dated Nov. 2, 2026 (last read Nov. 11, 2026) and American Independent Securities Group's Form ADV filings (latest 03/31/2026). Information, not investment advice.

Browse: [Investment advisers in Idaho](https://papertrailfinance.com/investment-advisers/idaho) · [All investment advisers](https://papertrailfinance.com/investment-advisers) · [Hand-decoded directory](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms)

## Key facts
Source for every key fact about American Independent Securities Group: SEC investment adviser data (https://www.sec.gov/data-research/sec-markets-data/information-about-registered-investment-advisers-exempt-reporting-advisers; the SEC's monthly adviser file dated Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026) and American Independent Securities Group's Form ADV (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288).
- Assets managed (Form ADV 5F): $986,332,007 (source: Form ADV Item 5.F, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of Nov. 2, 2026)
- Individual clients (5D): 4,339 (source: Form ADV Item 5.D, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of Nov. 2, 2026)
- Employees (5A): 49; offices: 37 (source: Form ADV Items 5.A and 1.F, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of Nov. 2, 2026)
- Disciplinary disclosures (Item 11): yes (source: Form ADV Item 11, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of Nov. 2, 2026)
- SEC record: https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288 (SEC data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026)

## The Paper Trail rating: 56/100 (confidence Medium; 7 of 8 factors scored)
Among rated advisers: not ranked among hand-decoded advisers because only 80% of the rubric's weight could be scored (ranking needs 85%).
American Independent Securities Group's rating, like every hand-decoded rating, shows confidence no higher than Medium: blind re-reads of published ratings found about 3 in 100 filing facts wrong after adjudication, and an overall score is typically within about ±3 points of the corrected value.
The margin of about ±3 points on American Independent Securities Group's rating covers errors in reading the filings, measured in the blind checks; it does not cover missing data. For American Independent Securities Group, 1 of the 8 factors could not be scored; scoring it at the median of the published firms instead of leaving it out would move its overall score by 7 points.
Source: The Paper Trail adviser scoring v2.7 (https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/methodology), computed from the sourced facts on this page; American Independent Securities Group's SEC data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026.
- Client reviews (20%): not scored: no public reviews found
- Regulatory record (15%): 7.5/10
- Complaint record (10%): 10.0/10
- Cost (15%): 4.0/10
- Fee transparency (10%): 6.0/10
- Conflicts of interest (15%): 1.5/10
- Disclosure consistency (10%): 6.0/10
- Fiduciary standing (5%): 6.0/10
Method (scoring v2.7): https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/methodology


## Questions and answers
### Is American Independent Securities Group registered, and who regulates it?
American Independent Securities Group is registered with the SEC as an investment adviser (CRD 135288, SEC file 801-69138), and the SEC regulates it. Its registration status in the SEC's record is "Approved". The SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure record for the firm lists its Form ADV, brochures and Form CRS.
Source: SEC investment adviser data as of Nov. 2, 2026, last read Nov. 11, 2026 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Is American Independent Securities Group a fiduciary?
American Independent Securities Group describes a fiduciary duty when acting as investment adviser; as a broker-dealer it says it must act in the client's best interest.
Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure / Form CRS (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Who is American Independent Securities Group for?
On average it manages about $225,000 per account and $223,000 per individual client (averages, not minimums). Individuals and high-net-worth individuals account for 98% of its assets.
Source: Form ADV Part 1A Items 5.D and 5.F (filed March 31, 2026); Form ADV Part 2A brochure (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### How much does American Independent Securities Group charge?
Under its main published fee schedule ("RBC Management Services (RBC Advisor, Consulting Solutions, RBC Unified Portfolios, uMAS)"), American Independent Securities Group charges 0.75% to 2.5% a year; on a $1 million account that is as much as $25,000. The firm says fees are negotiable.
Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Item 5 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Does American Independent Securities Group earn money other than advisory fees?
Its filings disclose commissions on securities or insurance, insurance sales by the firm or its people, 12b-1 or trail fees, revenue sharing from fund companies or platforms, an affiliated broker-dealer and payments for referring clients, which can give the firm or its people a financial interest in what they recommend. Each is quoted from the filing in the conflicts section.
Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Form CRS and Form ADV, as read and verified by The Paper Trail (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Who owns American Independent Securities Group?
American Independent Securities Group is owned 75% or more by its CEO, Ryan S. Carlson; no indirect owners are listed.
Source: Form ADV Schedule A (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Has American Independent Securities Group been disciplined by regulators?
American Independent Securities Group's Form ADV reports 2 disciplinary disclosures under Item 11, which covers the firm and its advisory affiliates (such as its officers and advisers). The filing has the details.
Source: Form ADV, latest filing 03/31/2026, Item 11 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### Does American Independent Securities Group have an account minimum?
Schwab-platform advisory accounts require at least $2,500; RBC programs state a minimum written as "$10,00.00" that may vary by platform. Minimums may be negotiable.
Source: Firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Item 7 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### How big is American Independent Securities Group?
It manages $986 million in regulatory assets and serves about 4,339 individual clients, with 49 employees and 37 offices.
Source: Form ADV, latest filing 03/31/2026, Items 5A, 5D and 5F (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### How many advisers does American Independent Securities Group have?
IAPD lists 47 investment adviser representatives at American Independent Securities Group (as of Oct. 14, 2026). Their median time in the industry is 25.8 years, and 87% have 10 or more years. 100% hold a Series 65 or 66 license.
Source: SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure, adviser records (firm totals only) (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288).

### How have American Independent Securities Group's assets changed over ten years?
Its regulatory assets under management went from $130 million in Oct 2016 to $986 million in Oct 2026, a compound change of +22.5% a year over ten years.
Source: SEC monthly registered-adviser files, one per year, Form ADV Item 5F(2)(c) (https://www.sec.gov/data-research/sec-markets-data/information-about-registered-investment-advisers-exempt-reporting-advisers).

### Who holds my money at American Independent Securities Group?
Client accounts are held at RBC CAPITAL MARKETS, LLC and ASSETMARK, INC. The firm reports in Form ADV Item 9 that it does not have custody of client assets.
Source: Form ADV Item 9 and Schedule D 5.K(3) (filed March 31, 2026); brochure Item 15 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 2, 2026.

### How is American Independent Securities Group rated on Google?
No Google reviews were found on the listings tied to the website American Independent Securities Group reports in its Form ADV (retrieved Oct. 14, 2026).
Source: Google's public review count and rating for the business listings on the firm's Form ADV website.

## Fees
Primary schedule: RBC Management Services (RBC Advisor, Consulting Solutions, RBC Unified Portfolios, uMAS): 0.75% to 2.50% a year, billed quarterly in advance; the firm says fees are negotiable.

What American Independent Securities Group's advisory fee comes to
| Account size | Per year | Effective rate | Over 20 years* |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| $250,000 | up to $6,250 | up to 2.50% | up to $304,336 |
| $500,000 | up to $12,500 | up to 2.50% | up to $608,672 |
| $1,000,000 | up to $25,000 | up to 2.50% | up to $1,217,346 |
| $2,000,000 | up to $50,000 | up to 2.50% | up to $2,434,691 |

Source: American Independent Securities Group's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Item 5 (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of 03/31/2026. Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 9): "Our annual fees for Investment Advisory Services are based upon a percentage of assets under management and generally range from .75% to 2.5%. The fee is negotiated and is based upon a variety of factors, including, but not limited to: total assets to be managed, scope of engagement, investment style and types of investments. Clients fees are deducted quarterly in advance for advisory services."

Advisory fee only, from American Independent Securities Group's published schedule; fund expenses, custody and trading costs are extra. *Over 20 years = how much less the account would hold after paying the fee each year, assuming a 6% annual return before fees and no withdrawals. Illustration, not a forecast.

## Conflicts of interest (from the firm's filings)
American Independent Securities Group's filings were read for 17 kinds of conflict of interest: 8 present, 4 unclear and 5 not present.
- Commissions: yes. The firm is also a broker-dealer, and its representatives earn commissions on securities transactions in brokerage accounts. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 16): "These individuals, in their separate capacity as registered representatives of our affiliated broker- dealer, can effect securities transactions for which they will receive separate, yet customary compensation."
- Insurance sales: yes. The firm's advisers may also be insurance agents who earn commissions on insurance products. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 17): "The management personnel and IAR's of our firm, in their individual capacities, may be agents for various insurance companies. As such, these individuals are able to receive separate, yet customary commission compensation resulting from insurance product transactions."
- 12b-1 / trail fees: yes. The firm may receive 12b-1 fees from mutual funds; it says these are rebated in advisory accounts held at RBC but may be charged in brokerage accounts. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 11): "AISG may receive a portion of the distribution or 12b-1 fees. Therefore, AISG advisory representatives may have an incentive to recommend one fund over another. 12b-1 or distribution fees will be rebated back on mutual funds held in AISG's investment advisory accounts custodian at RBC."
- Revenue sharing: yes. The firm receives revenue from other parties, including product sponsors that pay for educational meetings, which gives it an incentive to offer those products. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form CRS, p. 3): "Our firm receives revenue from other parties and has a financial incentive to offer products where the firm benefits."
- Own or affiliated products: no. The firm says it does not manage any proprietary investment funds. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12): "AISG does not manage any proprietary investment funds or limited partnerships (for example, a mutual fund or a hedge fund)."
- Affiliated broker-dealer: yes. The adviser is itself a FINRA-member broker-dealer, and its advisers may also act as its registered representatives. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 16): "In addition to AISG being a registered investment adviser, our firm is registered as a FINRA member broker-dealer."
- Pays for client referrals: unclear. The brochure describes the firm being paid for referrals but does not say whether it pays others for referring clients to it. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 21): "AISG may enter into solicitor/promoter agreements with third-party advisors under which the third-party advisor pays a fee to AISG for client referrals"
- Paid for referrals: yes. Outside investment advisers pay the firm a percentage of the fees from clients it refers to them. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 21): "The third-party advisors have agreed to pay AISG a percentage of the revenue generated from the assets of clients introduced to the third-party advisor by AISG. This fee percentage will be a fixed percentage of the total fees generated by the client."
- Benefits from custodians: yes. Charles Schwab gives the firm free or discounted research, technology and practice-management services and may pay for staff to attend conferences. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 19): "There is no direct link between our firm's participation in the program and the investment advice we give to our clients, although we receive economic benefits through our participation in the program that are typically not available to Charles Schwab retail investors."
- Soft dollars: no. The firm says it has no soft-dollar arrangements. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 18): "AISG does not have any soft-dollar arrangements and does not receive any soft-dollar benefits."
- Principal or cross trades: no. The brochure does not address principal or agency-cross trades; it says advisers may buy or sell the same securities they recommend to clients. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 18): "AISG allows our IARs to purchase or sell the same securities that may be recommended to and purchased on behalf of our clients."
- Performance-based fees: no. The firm does not charge performance-based fees. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12): "AISG does not charge performance-based fees for its investment advisory services."
- Private funds: no. The firm does not manage hedge funds or limited partnerships. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12): "AISG does not manage any proprietary investment funds or limited partnerships (for example, a mutual fund or a hedge fund)."
- Rollover recommendations: unclear. The brochure says the firm acts as a fiduciary for IRA clients under ERISA rules but does not discuss rollover recommendations. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 12): "AISG is deemed to be a fiduciary to advisory clients that are employee benefit plans or individual retirement accounts ("IRAs") pursuant to the Employee Retirement Income and Securities Act ("ERISA")"
- Outside business: unclear. Advisers' outside employment must be approved by the firm; the brochure does not describe specific outside businesses beyond brokerage and insurance. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 17): "AISG requires our IARs to seek prior approval of any outside employment activity so that we may ensure that any conflicts of interest in such activities are properly addressed."
- Other: yes. In RBC programs, advisers pay a per-trade fee once an account exceeds its allotted trades, which gives them a reason to trade less. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 20): "Accounts that exceed this allotted number of trades cost the IAR a per trade fee. This presents a conflict of interest in that advisory representatives may have an incentive to limit the number of trades in an account, even if such trading would benefit the client."
- Other: unclear. The brochure says financial-plan recommendations are limited to products offered through the broker-dealer and insurance companies advisers represent, but on the same page says they are not limited to any specific product of a broker-dealer or insurance company. (source: Form ADV Part 2A, Form CRS and Part 1A, https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288; as of 03/31/2026) Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7): "IAR's of AISG may be dually registered as representatives of a broker-dealer and/or as insurance agents/brokers of various insurance companies. Therefore, recommendations made in financial plans are limited to only those products offered through these companies."

## Ownership
American Independent Securities Group is owned 75% or more by its CEO, Ryan S. Carlson; no indirect owners are listed.
Source: Form ADV Schedules A and B (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of 03/31/2026. Quote (Form ADV Part 1, p. 38): "CARLSON, RYAN SHANE I MEMBER, CEO 03/2025 E Y N 4209072"

## Fiduciary status
American Independent Securities Group describes a fiduciary duty when acting as investment adviser; as a broker-dealer it says it must act in the client's best interest.
Source: Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of 03/31/2026. Quote (Form ADV Part 2A, p. 17): "As part of our fiduciary duty as a registered investment adviser; we take the following steps to address these conflicts:"

## Who it's for
- Average account (5F(2)(c) / 5F(2)(f)): $225,000; average per individual client: $223,000 (averages, not minimums)
- Account minimum: The $2,500 minimum for Schwab-platform advisory accounts may be negotiable; related accounts may be combined to meet it. RBC program minimums vary by platform.

| Client type (Form ADV 5.D) | Clients | Assets | Share of assets |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Individuals | 3,902 | $578,268,192 | 58.6% |
| High-net-worth individuals | 437 | $389,132,165 | 39.5% |
| Businesses | 15 | $8,562,321 | 0.9% |
| Pension and profit-sharing plans | 18 | $5,493,195 | 0.6% |
| Charitable organizations | 13 | $4,876,134 | 0.5% |

- Individuals and high-net-worth individuals account for 98.1% of the assets the firm manages.
- Services: Financial planning, Estate planning, Business owner planning, Outside managers, Hourly or project planning
- Not provided by the firm: Estate planning documents are created by the client through a third-party provider's software (EncorEstate Plans) for a separate fee; the firm gives no legal advice and drafts no documents.
- Not provided by the firm: The firm states it does not provide tax or legal advice and directs clients to their own tax and legal advisers and accountants.
- Investment approach: Individual advisers choose methods and strategies per client, including asset allocation, long- and short-term purchases, margin and options, often using third-party managers or custodial managed-account programs.
Source: Form ADV Part 1A Items 5.D and 5.F (filed March 31, 2026); Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS.

## Team
- Advisers (current investment adviser representatives on IAPD): 47
- Median years in the industry: 25.8; 10 or more years: 87%
- Series 65 or 66: 100%; Series 7: 92%; also with a broker-dealer: 100%
- Advisers with a disclosure on record: 30%
Source: SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure adviser records, retrieved Oct. 14, 2026; firm totals only, no individuals.

## Ten-year record
| SEC file | Assets under management | Individual clients |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Oct 2016 | $130,083,582 |  |
| Oct 2017 | $142,722,738 |  |
| Oct 2018 | $207,777,866 | 1,134 |
| Oct 2019 | $213,441,935 | 1,686 |
| Oct 2020 | $313,452,345 | 2,388 |
| Oct 2021 | $341,256,603 | 2,178 |
| Oct 2022 | $412,166,856 | 2,466 |
| Oct 2023 | $407,674,041 | 2,743 |
| Oct 2024 | $513,341,332 | 2,814 |
| Sep 2025 | $604,888,609 | 2,966 |
| Oct 2026 | $986,332,007 | 4,339 |

- Compound annual change in assets, ten years: 22.5%
- Compound annual change in assets, five years: 23.6%
Source: SEC monthly registered-adviser files, one per year (October; Sep 2025 because the SEC published no October file that year), Form ADV Items 5F(2)(c) and 5D(a)(1) + 5D(b)(1).

## How client money is held
American Independent Securities Group reports in Form ADV Item 9 that it does not have custody of client assets.
- Custodian: RBC CAPITAL MARKETS, LLC (Minneapolis, MN), holding $636M of the firm's separately managed account assets
- Custodian: ASSETMARK, INC (Concord, CA), holding $250M of the firm's separately managed account assets
- The brochure also names: Charles Schwab
- Affiliate (broker-dealer): American Independent Securities Group, LLC
- Affiliate (other investment adviser): American Independent Securities Group, LLC
- Affiliate (insurance company or agency): American Independent Securities Group, LLC
Source: Form ADV Part 1A Items 7 and 9, Schedule D 5.K(3), 7.A, 7.B(1) and 9.C (filed March 31, 2026); brochure Item 15.

## Client reviews
The Google listings tied to the firm's website have no reviews.
Source: Google's public review count and rating for the business listings on the firm's Form ADV website, retrieved Oct. 14, 2026. Rules: https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/methodology

## Where the firm's documents disagree
- Substantive (counts in the rating), other: The brochure says financial-plan recommendations are not limited to any broker-dealer's or insurance company's products, and on the same page says they are limited to the products offered through the companies the advisers represent.
  - Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: "Financial Planning recommendations are not limited to any specific product or service offered by a broker-dealer or insurance company."
  - Form ADV Part 2A, p. 7: "Therefore, recommendations made in financial plans are limited to only those products offered through these companies."
Source: the firm's Form ADV Part 2A brochure, Form CRS and Form ADV Part 1A (https://adviserinfo.sec.gov/firm/summary/135288); as of 03/31/2026.

## Also listed as broker-dealer

American Independent Securities Group, LLC is a broker-dealer headquartered in Eagle, Idaho. It is a retail-focused broker-dealer registered with FINRA since 2005, with net capital of $550,274 and 1 disclosure event of its own in its BrokerCheck and regulator records. The Paper Trail scores it 91 out of 100 with medium confidence, strongest on legal record and weakest on financial condition. Figures are as of Nov. 9, 2026.

## How does The Paper Trail rate American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer?

American Independent Securities Group, LLC scores 91 out of 100 as a broker-dealer, with medium confidence, as of Nov. 9, 2026: higher than 24% of the 258 rated broker-dealers that are ranked. 5 of 5 factors had enough evidence to score. 2 factors share the highest score, 10.0 of 10; the lowest is financial condition (8.0 of 10).

American Independent Securities Group, LLC's score combines regulatory record (35%), legal record (10%), customer dispute record (15%), financial condition (30%) and operating history (10%). It is not advice, not a rating of service, and it never rates individual representatives.

American Independent Securities Group, LLC was scored on 100% of the rubric's weight. Every factor in the rubric was scored.

**Score factors for American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer**

| Factor | Weight | Score (0-10) | Basis |
| --- | ---: | ---: | --- |
| Regulatory record | 35% | 9.4 | BrokerCheck lists 1 final regulatory action against the firm, the most recent in 2021, 0 of them in the last five years. The score counts recent and serious actions more heavily and scales for firm size (the firm has 54 branch offices on BrokerCheck; registered-representative counts are not published in these records). |
| Legal record | 10% | 10.0 | BrokerCheck lists no final civil, criminal, bankruptcy or judgment matters against this firm. |
| Customer dispute record | 15% | 10.0 | BrokerCheck lists no FINRA arbitration awards against this firm; settled cases are not public. |
| Financial condition | 30% | 8.0 | The firm's audited annual report for the year ended December 31, 2025 states net capital of $550,274 against a required minimum of $50,000, or 11.0 times the requirement. The report's cover page flags a material weakness. |
| Operating history | 10% | 9.0 | The firm has been registered with FINRA since August 18, 2005, about 21 years. |

**Notes on how each factor was computed**

- Operating history: registered with FINRA 21.2 years (since Aug. 18, 2005)

_American Independent Securities Group, LLC's score runs 0 to 100 and is computed from the factors above (a weighted mean of the scored factors, with N/A factors excluded). Missing data is never counted as good or bad; pending matters are shown but never scored; individuals are never rated._

- [How we rate broker-dealers: the written rubric](https://papertrailfinance.com/broker-dealers/methodology)

_Source: The Paper Trail's scoring under the written rubric for broker-dealers (/broker-dealers/methodology), from the sourced facts on this page; as of Nov. 9, 2026._

## What do public records say about American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer?

American Independent Securities Group, LLC's public records show a retail client focus, net capital of $550,274 and 1 disclosure event on BrokerCheck. They are among 16 sourced facts listed here as of Nov. 9, 2026. Each row gives its source, the exact quote or value read, and the date the source value is as of.

**Key facts about American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer, with sources**

| Fact | Value | Source | As of |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| BrokerCheck firm status | ACTIVE · Approved · since Aug. 18, 2005 | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Reported on BrokerCheck: ACTIVE; Approved; 08/18/2005) | Oct. 14, 2026 |
| FINRA firm size class | Small | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Reported on BrokerCheck: Small) | Oct. 14, 2026 |
| Branch offices on BrokerCheck | 54 | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Reported on BrokerCheck: 54) | Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Registered with FINRA since | Aug. 18, 2005 | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (“FINRA Approved 08/18/2005”) | Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Form CRS on file with BrokerCheck | Form CRS filed by a dually registered firm (broker-dealer and investment adviser) | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Value as filed: DU) | Oct. 14, 2026 |
| BrokerCheck disclosure counts by type | Regulatory Event: 1 | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Reported on BrokerCheck: Regulatory Event; 1) | Oct. 14, 2026 |
| Holds funds or securities or clears for other broker-dealers | No | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (“This firm does not hold or maintain funds or securities or provide clearing services for other broker-dealer[s]”) | Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Refers or introduces customers to other brokers and dealers | Yes | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (“This firm does refer or introduce customers to other brokers and dealers”) | Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Net capital (annual audited report) | $550,274 | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (Value as filed: net capital of $550,274, and net capital requirements of $50,000.) | Dec. 31, 2025 |
| Minimum net capital required (annual audited report) | $50,000 | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (Value as filed: net capital of $550,274, and net capital requirements of $50,000.) | Dec. 31, 2025 |
| Independent accountant named on the annual report cover page | LMHS, P.C. | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (Value as filed: LMHS, P.C.) | March 27, 2026 |
| Material weakness reported on the annual report cover page | Yes | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (As filed: Yes) | March 27, 2026 |
| Going-concern doubt language in the annual report | No | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (“No going-concern doubt stated: the report text has no sentence saying there is substantial doubt about the firm's ability to continue as a going concern”) | Dec. 31, 2025 |
| Latest annual audited report filed electronically on EDGAR | X-17A-5, period ending Dec. 31, 2025, filed March 27, 2026 | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (Listed in this register as: 0001324107-26-000001; March 27, 2026; Dec. 31, 2025) | Nov. 9, 2026 |

**All other sourced facts (2)**

The other 2 sourced facts about American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer, as of Nov. 9, 2026, each with its source and date.

**Other sourced facts about American Independent Securities Group, LLC as a broker-dealer**

| Fact | Value | Source | As of |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Types of business (BrokerCheck) | Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; Mutual fund retailer; U S. government securities broker; Municipal securities broker; Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities; Broker or dealer selling oil and gas interests; Put and call broker or dealer or option writer; Investment advisory services; Broker or dealer selling tax shelters or limited partnerships in primary distributions; Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member; Private placements of securities; Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: bank, savings bank or association, or credit union; Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: insurance company or agency | [brokercheck.finra.org](https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288) (Value as filed: Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; Mutual fund retailer; U S. government securities broker; Municipal securities broker; Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities; Broker or dealer selling oil and gas interests; Put and call broker or dealer or option writer; Investment advisory services; Broker or dealer selling tax shelters or limited partnerships in primary distributions; Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member; Private placements of securities; Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: bank, savings bank or association, or credit union; Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: insurance company or agency) | Nov. 9, 2026 |
| Audit report states the statements present fairly, in all material respects | Yes | [sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1324107/000132410726000001/) (“present fairly, in all material respects”) | Dec. 31, 2025 |

## What lines of business is American Independent Securities Group, LLC in?

American Independent Securities Group, LLC reports 14 lines of business on its broker-dealer registration: broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter; broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities; mutual fund retailer; and 11 more, listed below.

- Broker or dealer retailing corporate equity securities over-the-counter
- Broker or dealer selling corporate debt securities
- Mutual fund retailer
- U.S. government securities broker
- Municipal securities broker
- Broker or dealer selling variable life insurance or annuities
- Broker or dealer selling oil and gas interests
- Put and call broker or dealer or option writer
- Investment advisory services
- Broker or dealer selling tax shelters or limited partnerships in primary distributions
- Non-exchange member arranging for transactions in listed securities by exchange member
- Private placements of securities
- Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: bank, savings bank or association, or credit union
- Broker or dealer involved in a networking, kiosk or similar arrangment with a: insurance company or agency

_Source: FINRA BrokerCheck (https://brokercheck.finra.org/firm/summary/135288); as of Nov. 9, 2026._

## Does American Independent Securities Group, LLC have a regulatory or legal record as a broker-dealer?

The records below list 1 matter for American Independent Securities Group, LLC. Matters concerning the firm itself: 1 final, 0 pending, 0 other. It concerns the firm itself. 1 of the firm's own matters was settled with the firm neither admitting nor denying the findings. Pending matters are allegations or unresolved proceedings: they are shown and labeled, and never scored. Individuals are never named or rated.

**Regulatory, legal and complaint matters for American Independent Securities Group, LLC**

| Date | Regulator or court | Matter | Concerns | Status | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| March 29, 2021 | FINRA | Regulatory matter; Acceptance, Waiver & Consent(AWC) (without admitting or denying the findings); Censure, Disgorgement/Restitution; initiated March 29, 2021; disgorgement or restitution $275,000; ref. 2018060267902 | the firm | Final; settled, neither admitted nor denied | [files.brokercheck.finra.org](https://files.brokercheck.finra.org/firm/firm_135288.pdf) (FINRA BrokerCheck report; as filed: Current Status: Final \| Initiated By: FINRA \| Date Initiated: 03/29/2021 \| Docket/Case Number: 2018060267902 \| Resolution: Acceptance, Waiver & Consent(AWC) \| Resolution Date: 03/29/2021 \| PARTIAL RESTITUTION TO CUSTOMERS OF $275,000; also in: [FINRA monthly disciplinary actions report](https://www.finra.org/sites/default/files/2021-05/Disciplinary_Actions_May_2021_1.pdf)) |

**How the record was searched (1)**

- [The Paper Trail reviewed a search of the SEC's enforcement lists on Nov. 9, 2026: it found no name hits and read 7 primary-source pages and 6 other leads. No matter from this search is listed separately; 1 matter is recorded as a second source of the same BrokerCheck disclosure; the search was complete.](https://www.finra.org/sites/default/files/2021-05/Disciplinary_Actions_May_2021_1.pdf)

## How does American Independent Securities Group, LLC compare with other broker-dealers in Idaho?

American Independent Securities Group, LLC ranks 1 of 4 broker-dealers headquartered in Idaho in this dataset by net capital ($550,274); size is available for 3 of them.

**American Independent Securities Group, LLC and nearby broker-dealers in Idaho, ordered by net capital**

| # | Firm | City | Net capital | Score |
| ---: | --- | --- | ---: | ---: |
| 1 | American Independent Securities Group | Eagle | $550,274 | 91 |
| 2 | [Avid Capital Advisors LLC](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/avid-capital-advisors-320717) | McCall | $253,302 | 93 |
| 3 | [Prager Partners, LLC](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/prager-partners-340801) | Ketchum | N/A | Rating on hold |
| 4 | [Silverbox Securities LLC](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/silverbox-securities-327513) | Ketchum | $15,529 | 93 |

## How is the score calculated?

American Independent Securities Group, LLC is assessed under the written rubric for its firm type. A factor is scored 0 to 10 from sourced facts, each factor has a published weight, factors without enough evidence are excluded and the rest are re-weighted, and a score is published only when the rubric's publication gate is met and the record's facts have been checked a second time (how American Independent Securities Group, LLC's facts were checked is under "Where does this information come from?").

- [How we rate broker-dealers](https://papertrailfinance.com/broker-dealers/methodology)

## When each source was read

- SEC monthly adviser file, read Nov. 11, 2026
- Form ADV Part 2A brochures and Form CRS, read Oct. 14, 2026
- Google reviews, read Oct. 14, 2026

## Compare with other Idaho advisers
| Firm | City | Assets | Individual clients | Fee on $1M |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| American Independent Securities Group | Eagle | $986M | 4,339 | up to $25,000 |
| [Continuum Advisory](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/continuum-advisory-283155) | Eagle | $1.9B | 3,344 | up to $29,500 |
| [Legacy Wealth Management](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/legacy-wealth-management-174767) | Boise | $629M | 3,269 | up to $20,000 |
| [Pinkerton Wealth Partners](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/pinkerton-wealth-partners-120973) | Coeur D'Alene | $1.4B | 1,233 | up to $20,000 |
| [Sand Creek Capital](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/sand-creek-capital-326719) | Rexburg | $471M | 939 | up to $20,000 |
| [HRC Wealth Management](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/hrc-wealth-management-117212) | Moscow | $487M | 878 | up to $10,000 |
| [RW Investment Management](https://papertrailfinance.com/firms/rw-investment-management-282707) | Eagle | $1.7B | 758 | N/A |

