---
title: "How We Rate Banks"
canonical: "https://papertrailfinance.com/banks/methodology"
as_of: 2026-06-30
updated: 2026-06-30
type: methodology
publisher: "The Paper Trail"
firm_type: "banks"
sources:
  - name: "FDIC's BankFind Suite"
    url: "https://banks.data.fdic.gov/bankfind-suite/bankfind"
---

# How We Rate Banks

The Paper Trail profiles 404 banks and scores them on version 1.7 of a written rubric; 395 have a published score. This page is the rubric as the rating program applies it: each factor and its weight, the evidence it uses, when a factor is left out, and the gate a score must pass. Most recent data: June 30, 2026.

The scoring program and the second program that recomputes every score on each rebuild were written by the same research team, so the second program checks the arithmetic, not the reading of the rules. The check of the written rules is a re-implementation by a different reviewer, who built the rubric from this page alone without opening either program. When run against version 1.7 of this rubric on Nov. 11, 2026, the re-implementation matched every factor score, overall score, confidence level and publication decision for all 404 banks. Version 1.7, the one on this page, is the version that re-implementation checked.

## What weights does the rating program use?

These weights are read from the scored profiles themselves, so they match every score on the site (395 published). A factor without enough evidence for a firm is left out and the remaining weights are scaled up to 100%.

| Factor | Weight |
| --- | --- |
| Capital strength | 28% |
| Asset quality | 22% |
| Enforcement record | 16% |
| CRA rating | 12% |
| Earnings | 11% |
| Funding and liquidity | 11% |


Scope: every active FDIC-insured bank headquartered in the 13 West states (397 on June 30, 2026; State Bank Northwest, which filed no June 30, 2026 Call Report, is profiled from its latest quarter and held). A program applies the written rules below, and a second program recomputes every trial score from the facts.

## Which factors are scored, and how much does each weigh?

| Factor | Key | Weight | Inputs (FDIC BankFind RISVIEW, June 30, 2026, unless noted) | Outside record? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capital strength | capital | 28% | Tier 1 leverage, CET1, Tier 1 and total risk-based ratios; CBLR election | no (regulator-published Call Report data) |
| Asset quality | asset quality | 22% | Noncurrent loans / loans, nonperforming assets / assets, net charge-offs / loans | no |
| Earnings | earnings | 11% | Return on assets, efficiency ratio | no |
| Funding and liquidity | liquidity | 11% | Brokered deposits / deposits, estimated uninsured deposits / deposits | no |
| Enforcement record | enforcement | 16% | FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders (every bank, by FDIC certificate), plus OCC formal actions (OCC monthly lists 2018 to date) or Federal Reserve actions (Board enforcement data file) for the banks those agencies supervise | **yes** |
| CRA rating | cra | 12% | Latest published CRA overall rating (FDIC, OCC and Federal Reserve lists) | **yes** |

**Consumer complaints are a displayed, unscored fact (v1.1).** Name-matched CFPB coverage is 31% of banks (122 of 397: 10 matched, 112 provably absent), under a 40% bar, and holding-company mapping (7 candidates, 5 accepted by a second reviewer) adds a handful. Complaint counts, timeliness and relief counts stay on each page (the CFPB complaint fields facts), labeled "not scored".

Each factor is scored 0 to 10. **A factor with no usable data is N/A and the remaining weights are renormalized; the page names the factors scored.** Missing data is never treated as good or bad. Each factor score is published to one decimal (rounded half-up, v1.5) and the overall is computed from those published scores: weighted mean of the scored factors x 10, rounded once, half-up (0 to 100); factor scores are stored to one decimal, as shown on the page (v1.5). Pending matters and allegations are shown and never scored; individuals are never rated and orders against individuals never attach to a bank.

Fiduciary activity (Schedule RC-T: fiduciary and related assets, accounts, income) is a **profile fact, not a factor**: more fiduciary assets is neither better nor worse. It is shown for the 35 banks (of 397) that report fiduciary assets above zero and 50 that report any activity.

## Which thresholds are used, and where do they come from?

### How is capital strength scored (28% of the score)?
- Per-measure thresholds are the prompt-corrective-action definitions (12 CFR 324.403(b)): adequately / well capitalized = leverage 4 / 5; CET1 4.5 / 6.5; Tier 1 risk-based 6 / 8; total risk-based 8 / 10 (percent).
- For one measure r with adequate threshold A, well threshold W and West P90 value P (from the underlying records): r < A scores 0; A <= r < W scores 2 + 3 x (r - A)/(W - A); r >= W scores 5 + 5 x the smaller of 1 and (r - W)/(P - W). Reading: 5 = at the "well capitalized" line, 10 = at or above the West P90 of that ratio.
- **Capital = the minimum of the measure scores** (prompt corrective action takes the lowest applicable category).
- A bank that elected the community bank leverage ratio framework (CBLRIND = 1) is scored on the Tier 1 leverage ratio alone, as the regulation allows; risk-based P90 anchors are computed from non-CBLR banks only.
- Nov. 9, 2026 anchors: leverage 17.86%, CET1 29.53%, Tier 1 RBC 29.65%, total RBC 30.79%.
- N/A when no capital ratio is available (Mizrahi Tefahot Bank reports all four ratios as 0: not reported).

### How is asset quality scored (22% of the score)?
- Noncurrent loans / loans (weight 50%), nonperforming assets / assets (25%), net charge-offs / loans (25%). Each is scaled linearly from the West **P90 (score 0) to P10 (score 10)** (lower is better). Anchors Nov. 9, 2026: noncurrent 0.00% to 2.47%; NPA 0.00% to 1.77%; net charge-offs -0.004% to 0.705%.
- Needs at least 2 of the 3 measures, else N/A. Weights of any missing measure are renormalized.

### How is earnings scored (11% of the score)?
- Return on assets 60% (P10 0.197% scores 0, P90 2.406% scores 10), efficiency ratio 40% (P90 88.4% scores 0, P10 39.6% scores 10; a ratio <= 0 is dropped).

### How is funding and liquidity scored (11% of the score)?
- Brokered deposits / deposits and estimated uninsured deposits / deposits (FDIC estimate), 50% each, each scaled P90 (0) to P10 (10). Anchors: brokered 13.39% to 0.00%; uninsured 50.83% to 10.94%. At least one needed. These are runoff-risk indicators, not a verdict on management.

### How is enforcement record scored (16% of the score)?
- Searched for **every bank** (v1.2) in **FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders** (orders.fdic.gov; robots rules allow every path but a password page), by FDIC certificate number through the search form's own server actions (404 certificates, 155 with at least one order record). A by-state search of the same system is the cross-check (401 of 404 agree; the 3 differences are orders the certificate search found and the state search did not, because the order lists the bank under another state). In addition, **OCC-supervised banks** (76) are searched in the OCC monthly releases (104 releases 2018 to Nov. 9, 2026) and **Federal Reserve-supervised banks** (62) in the Board's enforcement actions data file. Counts from the lists add up.
- FDIC records: one action per docket (ED&O carries duplicate records and procedural decisions under the same docket; docket numbers are compared without leading zeros); an action is against the bank only when a respondent is an institution; orders against individuals are shown without names and never scored; notices of charges are pending and not scored; termination orders end the action with the same docket.
- Every FDIC action that moves a score (29) was checked against the signed order document (the PDF the record links): all 29 name the bank (current or former FDIC legal name) and carry the docket. A seeded 10% sample (40 banks) searched again by bank name found no order the certificate search missed.
- Score = 10 - 4 for each formal action still in force (cease-and-desist, consent order, formal agreement, PCA directive; in force until an OCC termination or a superseding order is listed) - 2 for each action terminated, or one-time order (civil money penalty, restitution), in the last 5 years (since Nov. 9, 2021) - 1 for each civil money penalty of $250,000 or more in the last 5 years (when the release states the amount); floor 0.
- N/A when an OCC line naming the bank cannot be classified (old-format tables with no action heading): an enforcement search that could not be classified.
- Pending matters (notices of charges) shown, never scored.
- CFPB enforcement actions (static list, 386 actions) naming a bank are shown in the outside record with the status read from the action page, and a filing without a "Expired/Terminated/Dismissed" status holds the rating; they are shown and never scored (the factor table has no CFPB enforcement input in any version).

### Why are consumer complaints shown but not scored?
- Source: CFPB Consumer Complaint Database API, complaints received in the 36 months to Nov. 9, 2026. The database has no charter id, so a bank is matched by exact normalized name only (punctuation and "N.A." ignored; "Corporation", "Inc.", "Bancorp" are not ignored), one candidate, and for banks under $10B at least 40% of the complaints must come from the home state.
- **Matched** (10 banks) or **none-in-database** (112 banks: searching the firm's longest non-generic word and its first two non-generic words returns no company string, so the database holds nothing under the name; count = 0).
- Rate = complaints / 3 years / max(assets in $ billions, 1). Score = 10 x (1 - min(1, rate / P90 of the positive rates)); the West P90 of positive rates (8 banks) is 6.25 per $1B-year. Requires at least 5 banks with a positive rate, else N/A for all.
- Every other bank (275) is N/A: unresolved is not zero. 
- The rate measures complaints filed with a federal agency and says nothing about satisfaction.

### How is cRA rating scored (12% of the score)?
- Latest overall rating in the FDIC "Monthly List of Banks Examined for CRA Compliance" (118 monthly pages, 2017 to 2026-11; matched on FDIC certificate) or the OCC monthly CRA lists (104 releases, 2018 to 2026; matched on name + city + state, or exact name alone for banks of $10B or more); the most recent evaluation wins.
- Outstanding 10; Satisfactory 7; Needs to Improve 2; Substantial Noncompliance 0. The rating date is always shown.
- N/A when the bank is in none of the three lists (the FDIC list, the OCC lists and the Federal Reserve's CRA ratings listing, which v1.1 added and describes; wholesale and limited-purpose banks are often exempt).

## How is confidence set?
Points: +1 for each outside-record factor scored (maximum 2); +1 if at least 3 of the 4 financial factors are scored; +1 if the trial record was independently verified (a second reviewer re-derived every fact from the cached source and no mismatch remains open). **High 4 or 5, Medium 3, Low 2 or fewer.**

## How much of the rubric is scored for each firm?
Every firm file carries share of the rubric's weight that was scored (the share of the rubric's weight that was actually scored) and the factors left unscored, each with its reason (each N/A factor with its weight and the reason). When a factor of 25% weight or more is N/A, or less than 75% of the weight is scored, confidence is at most Medium and the file carries a plain note on confidence; under 60% the rating is held ("not enough of the rubric could be scored"). Measured on Nov. 11, 2026: of the 395 published bank ratings, 376 have 100% of the weight scored, 18 have 88% (no CRA rating) and 1 has 72% (capital not reported); that one moves from High to Medium confidence. No rating is held by the rule and no overall changes.

## How are firms ranked when data is missing?
Every firm file carries eligibility for ranking, ranking note, percentile within its type and rank within its type (re-derived by the audit). A firm is rank-eligible when it has a published rating, at least 85% of the rubric's weight is scored, and it does not reach the top tenth only because of a data gap. Percentiles and ranks are computed over rank-eligible firms only; other firms carry a plain ranking note and no percentile. Data-gap test: each rated firm's overall recomputed with every N/A factor at the type median of that factor instead of renormalising. Measured Nov. 11, 2026: 395 rated, 19 with a gap, rank correlation 0.9996, 2 firms move 3 points or more (largest change 3); no firm reaches the top tenth only because of a data gap; 394 firms are rank-eligible.

## When is a score published?
A rating is published only when ALL hold; otherwise it is held and the page says why:
1. At least **5 of the 6** factors are scored.
2. At least one **outside-record** factor (enforcement or CRA) is scored.
3. Confidence is Medium or High.
4. The firm's facts were **independently verified** (no unresolved mismatch). 4a. **Double confirmation:** a bank scoring under 40, or below an adequately-capitalized line, must pass a recorded double confirmation (two pulls and a clean prior-two-quarter history), else held.
5. No unresolved enforcement lead: a web search or regulator lead naming an action against the bank, or a CFPB enforcement action without a terminated status, that has not been read against the primary record holds the rating.

The whole universe is scored and was independently verified on Nov. 9, 2026 (a separate reviewer's parse of every field plus a blind 5% manual sample); a firm publishes only when its own verification status is "verified" and the gate passes.

## What does a profile show that is not scored?
Charter, regulator, holding company, offices, established date; fiduciary assets, accounts and income (RC-T); net interest margin; trust powers code; the outside record (FDIC, OCC and Federal Reserve actions, CFPB complaint counts and timeliness for matched banks, CFPB enforcement actions and status, CRA rating and date, reviewed leads each labeled; every item in name-free wording).

## How sensitive are the scores to the weights?
The largest weight is capital at 28%: a bank scoring 10 on every other factor and 5 on capital scores 86 instead of 100 (28% x 5 points x 10 = 14 points). Each weight moved by 5 points (others unchanged, scored weights renormalised per firm), overall recomputed for the 397 active banks:

| Factor | Shift | Spearman vs baseline | Median change | Max change | Firms moving 3+ points | Top 10% kept |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| capital | +5 | 0.995 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 95% |
| capital | -5 | 0.996 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 95% |
| asset quality | +5 | 0.993 | 1 | 3 | 18 | 95% |
| asset quality | -5 | 0.989 | 1 | 4 | 23 | 92% |
| earnings | +5 | 0.986 | 1 | 5 | 66 | 87% |
| earnings | -5 | 0.982 | 1 | 6 | 85 | 87% |
| liquidity | +5 | 0.991 | 1 | 3 | 18 | 95% |
| liquidity | -5 | 0.988 | 1 | 4 | 26 | 92% |
| enforcement | +5 | 0.998 | 1 | 3 | 7 | 100% |
| enforcement | -5 | 0.997 | 1 | 3 | 9 | 95% |
| cra | +5 | 0.995 | 0 | 3 | 6 | 95% |
| cra | -5 | 0.995 | 0 | 4 | 9 | 92% |

No shift changes any overall by more than 6 points and rank correlation stays above 0.98. Rank among scored banks also changes with the set of scored factors, so the page shows the overall and the factors it rests on.

## How complete are the fields on these profiles?

For each field, how many of the 404 bank profiles carry a value; how many have the source read and the field blank or not reported there ("not disclosed in the source"); and how many have no such fact at all ("not collected").

**Field completeness, 404 bank profiles**

| Field | Present | Not disclosed in the source | Not collected |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: |
| Name | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| City | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| State | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| FDIC certificate | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Total assets | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Capital ratios | 403 (99.8%) | 1 (0.2%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Asset quality | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Earnings | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Uninsured deposits | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| CRA rating | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Enforcement search | 404 (100.0%) | 0 (0.0%) | 0 (0.0%) |
| Website | 389 (96.3%) | 8 (2.0%) | 7 (1.7%) |

## What changed in each version?

- **Data note, Nov. 11, 2026: rubric stays v1.7.**
- **Version 1.7, Nov. 11, 2026: peer anchors follow the written rules.** The independent re-implementation found that the efficiency peer set kept one bank whose efficiency ratio is 0, although the rule drops a ratio at or below 0; the rating program now drops it (and, under the written rule, would exclude a non-active bank from the peers; none was in the set). Effect: 40 earnings factor scores change (by one decimal step), 1 overall changes; no publication, confidence or rank-eligibility change.
- **Version 1.6, Nov. 11, 2026: identity rule.** Effect: 0 overall changes; 2 publication changes; confidence and rank eligibility unchanged.
- **Version 1.5, Nov. 10, 2026: one rounding rule for every type.** Each factor score is rounded half-up to one decimal and the overall is computed from those one-decimal scores, so a reader (and the site) recomputes the overall exactly from the factor scores shown.
- **Version 1.4, Nov. 10, 2026.** Ranking and data gaps: eligibility for ranking (85% of weight scored, no top-tenth-only-by-gap), percentiles and ranks over rank-eligible firms only; 392 of 393 banks rated at the time were rank-eligible when v1.4 came in (Nov. 10, 2026); 394 of 395 are on Nov. 11, 2026.
- **Version 1.3, Nov. 10, 2026.** Coverage rule above (share of the rubric's weight that was scored, the factors left unscored, each with its reason, note on confidence; cap at Medium when a 25%+ factor is N/A or under 75% is scored; held under 60%). Effect: 1 published bank High to Medium, none held, no overall changed.
- **Version 1.2, Nov. 10, 2026.** Enforcement is searched for every bank in FDIC Enforcement Decisions and Orders by certificate, so the 259 FDIC-supervised banks are no longer left out (enforcement coverage 35% to 100%); the counting rule is the one used for the OCC and Federal Reserve lists. Effect: 262 of 404 files change their overall (active banks: median +4, range -8 to +9, because most FDIC-supervised banks gain an enforcement score of 10 and 21 banks have a counted FDIC action).
- **Version 1.1, Nov. 9, 2026.** Federal Reserve enforcement added from the Board's data file (62 banks; enforcement coverage 19% to 35%).
- **Version 1.1 addendum, Nov. 9, 2026: institution status.**
- **Version 1.0, Nov. 9, 2026.** First rubric.

This page is the written rubric the rating program follows, with file names and internal codes put in words. Individuals are never rated, pending matters and allegations are shown but never scored, and missing data is never counted as good or bad. Information, not investment advice.
